Icmcapital.co.uk Review

Based on looking at the website, ICM Capital (icmcapital.co.uk) operates in the realm of Forex, CFDs (Contracts for Difference), and Commodities trading. From an ethical standpoint, particularly within an Islamic framework, this platform is not recommended. The primary reason is its involvement in CFDs and Forex trading, which inherently involve Riba (interest) and excessive Gharar (uncertainty/speculation). These elements are strictly forbidden in Islamic finance due to their exploitative nature and the high risk of financial loss without tangible asset exchange. While the website highlights “Professional Clients Only” and mentions features like “Very Tight Spreads” and “Leverage up to 1:200,” these very aspects contribute to the impermissible nature of the transactions. The high leverage, in particular, amplifies both potential gains and losses, pushing the activity further into speculative territory.

Here’s an overall review summary:

• Platform Type: Online trading platform for Forex, CFDs, and Commodities.
• Target Audience: Primarily “Professional Clients Only.”
• Key Features Highlighted: Very Tight Spreads, Market Execution, Ultra-fast Execution, Deep Liquidity, Leveraged Trading (up to 1:200), Variety of Products, Award-winning Client Services Team, Market Leading Insurance.
• Ethical Review (Islamic Perspective): Forbidden due to inherent Riba (interest) and excessive Gharar (uncertainty/speculation) in Forex and CFD trading. The use of leverage further exacerbates the issue.
• Recommendation: Not recommended for Muslim individuals seeking Sharia-compliant financial activities.

Engaging in Forex and CFD trading, regardless of the platform’s features or awards, fundamentally clashes with Islamic financial principles. The core issue lies in the contractual nature of these instruments, where money is exchanged for money with a delay (Riba) or where the underlying asset is not actually owned or exchanged (Gharar). These transactions create wealth through mere price fluctuations rather than productive economic activity or genuine trade, leading to a zero-sum game often at the expense of others. It’s akin to gambling, which offers quick gains but often leads to significant losses and does not contribute to societal well-being.

Instead of engaging in speculative trading, it is far more beneficial and permissible to explore ethical and productive avenues for wealth generation and financial growth. These alternatives focus on real asset ownership, ethical investments, and tangible services, ensuring transactions are free from Riba, Gharar, and Maysir (gambling).

Best Alternatives for Ethical Financial Growth and Productivity:

• Islamic Finance & Investment Funds: These funds invest in Sharia-compliant businesses and assets, avoiding industries such as alcohol, tobacco, gambling, and conventional finance. They ensure that investments adhere to ethical guidelines and contribute to the real economy. Look for funds managed by reputable Islamic financial institutions.
• Ethical Savings Accounts (UK): Many ethical banks and building societies offer savings accounts that avoid investing in harmful industries or engage in Riba. While not always explicitly “Islamic,” some align closely with ethical principles. Always check their investment policies.
• Crowdfunding Platforms for Ethical Businesses: Platforms that allow investment in start-ups and small businesses focused on ethical products or services. This provides direct support to productive ventures and shares in their actual profits or losses, aligning with Islamic partnership principles.
• Real Estate Investment Trusts (REITs) – Sharia-compliant: While REITs can be complex, Sharia-compliant versions focus on real estate ownership and rental income, avoiding debt-based financing and interest. Investing in physical assets and generating real income from them is permissible.
• Gold and Silver as Physical Assets: Investing in physical gold and silver bullion can be a Sharia-compliant way to preserve wealth, provided it’s done with immediate exchange and possession, avoiding speculative contracts or deferred payments. It acts as a store of value rather than a speculative instrument.
• Direct Investment in Small Businesses: Becoming a direct investor or partner in a small, ethical business that produces tangible goods or services. This embodies the spirit of Mudarabah (profit-sharing) and Musharakah (joint venture), where both parties share risks and rewards.
• Sustainable and Ethical Investment Portfolios: Many mainstream investment firms now offer “ESG” (Environmental, Social, Governance) portfolios. While not exclusively Islamic, these often overlap with Islamic principles by avoiding industries with negative societal impacts. Careful due diligence is required to ensure alignment with Sharia principles, especially regarding interest-bearing instruments.

Find detailed reviews on Trustpilot, Reddit, and BBB.org, for software products you can also check Producthunt.

IMPORTANT: We have not personally tested this company’s services. This review is based solely on information provided by the company on their website. For independent, verified user experiences, please refer to trusted sources such as Trustpilot, Reddit, and BBB.org.

[ratemypost]

ICMcapital.co.uk Review & First Look

Upon a thorough examination of icmcapital.co.uk, the immediate impression is one of a professional and established online trading platform, particularly targeting “Professional Clients Only.” The website presents a clean, corporate design, complete with essential contact information like a UK phone number (+44 207 634 9770) and email ([email protected]). This immediate availability of contact details is a positive sign for any online service, indicating transparency and accessibility. However, it’s crucial to understand the nature of the services offered. ICM Capital focuses on Forex, CFDs, and Commodities trading, which, from an Islamic ethical perspective, raises significant concerns due to the inherent presence of Riba (interest) and excessive Gharar (uncertainty and speculation).

The homepage prominently displays calls to action like “Fund your Account” and “Start trading with ICM Capital,” alongside disclaimers regarding the high risk associated with CFDs and Spot FX. This warning is a standard regulatory requirement and underscores the volatile nature of these financial instruments. The platform highlights various features designed to attract serious traders, such as “Very Tight Spreads,” “Ultra-fast Execution,” and “Deep Liquidity from Tier-1 Banks.” These technical aspects aim to provide a competitive trading environment. Yet, for a Muslim audience, the underlying permissibility of the trading activities themselves supersedes any technological advantages. The emphasis on “Leverage up to 1:200” is particularly problematic, as leverage magnifies both profits and losses, pushing the activity further into speculative and debt-based realms, which are impermissible in Islam.

Understanding the Platform’s Focus

ICM Capital’s main offering revolves around leveraged trading of financial derivatives. This means traders aren’t buying or selling actual currencies or commodities but rather contracts that derive their value from the price movements of these underlying assets. This distinction is vital in Islamic finance.

• Derivatives and Sharia: The use of derivatives like CFDs is generally considered impermissible in Islam. This is because they often involve the exchange of money for money with a delay, creating Riba, and they lack the direct transfer of ownership or tangible assets, leading to Gharar.
• Leverage and Riba: Leverage, which allows traders to control large positions with a small amount of capital, is fundamentally an interest-bearing loan from the broker. This direct involvement with Riba, whether explicit or implicit, makes leveraged trading haram (forbidden).
• Speculation (Maysir): The rapid buying and selling of these instruments, driven by price predictions, often falls into the category of Maysir (gambling). While some level of risk is inherent in any business, the excessive and often zero-sum nature of short-term speculative trading is explicitly prohibited.

Initial Trust Signals (from a secular perspective)

Beyond the Islamic permissibility, the website does present some indicators that might be considered positive from a general trust perspective.

• Regulation: The presence of a “Regulation” link suggests that ICM Capital operates under specific financial regulatory bodies, which typically provides a layer of client protection. For instance, being regulated in the UK would imply oversight by the Financial Conduct Authority (FCA).
• Awards: The website proudly showcases numerous “Awards” for “Best Forex Customer Service Broker UK 2023,” “Best Forex Broker Asia 2023,” and “Excellent Trade Executions Middle East 2023.” While awards can sometimes be marketing tools, a consistent track record of recognition across different regions might indicate a certain level of industry standing.
• Sponsorships: The “Sponsorships” section, mentioning partnerships with entities like Swisspod Technologies and the France SailGP Team, suggests a company with significant financial backing and a desire for public visibility. These kinds of partnerships often require substantial capital.
• Contact Information: As mentioned, clear contact details are a fundamental trust signal. It shows that the company is reachable and not operating in anonymity.

Despite these secular indicators of trustworthiness, the core financial products offered remain incompatible with Islamic principles. Therefore, for someone adhering to Sharia, the platform’s overall legitimacy from a conventional business standpoint does not override its impermissibility from an ethical one. Dalin.co.uk Review

Best Alternatives for Ethical Financial Growth and Productivity

For individuals seeking to grow their wealth in a manner consistent with Islamic principles, the focus should shift from speculative derivatives to real economic activity, asset-backed investments, and profit-and-loss sharing ventures. These alternatives prioritize ethical conduct, social responsibility, and the avoidance of Riba, Gharar, and Maysir.

• Islamic Finance & Investment Funds: These funds rigorously screen investments to ensure they are Sharia-compliant, avoiding sectors like alcohol, tobacco, gambling, conventional banking, and arms manufacturing. They typically invest in ethical businesses that contribute positively to society. Key features often include:

  • Sharia Board Oversight: Independent scholars ensure compliance.
  • Asset-Backed Investments: Focus on real assets rather than purely financial instruments.
  • No Riba: Explicitly avoid interest-bearing transactions.
  • Transparent Reporting: Clear disclosure of investment methodologies.
  • Average Price: Management fees typically range from 0.5% to 2% annually.
  • Pros: Peace of mind regarding ethical compliance, diversification, professional management.
  • Cons: Limited investment universe compared to conventional funds, potentially higher fees.

• Ethical Savings Accounts (UK): Provided by banks and building societies committed to ethical banking practices. While not always explicitly “Islamic,” many align with principles of social responsibility and avoidance of harmful industries. It’s crucial to research their specific investment policies. Key features:

  • Socially Responsible Investing: Funds are often directed towards sustainable projects or ethical businesses.
  • Transparency: Clear communication on where deposits are utilised.
  • Variable Returns: Returns are typically based on ethical principles rather than interest.
  • Average Price: No direct cost to open, but returns might be lower than some conventional accounts.
  • Pros: Supports ethical causes, avoids conventional interest, relatively low risk.
  • Cons: Returns may not be competitive, limited choice of providers.

• Crowdfunding Platforms for Ethical Businesses: Platforms like Seedrs or Crowdcube allow individuals to invest directly in promising start-ups and growing businesses that align with ethical values. This model supports real economic growth and can offer high returns based on business success, reflecting Mudarabah or Musharakah principles. Key features:

  • Direct Investment: Own a share of a real business.
  • Variety of Sectors: Opportunities in technology, sustainability, halal food, etc.
  • Equity or Debt-Based (check carefully): Focus on equity or profit-sharing to avoid Riba.
  • Average Price: Investment amounts can start from as little as £10.
  • Pros: High potential for returns, direct support for entrepreneurs, aligns with risk-sharing.
  • Cons: High risk of capital loss (start-ups can fail), illiquidity of investment.

• Real Estate Investment Trusts (REITs) – Sharia-compliant: These involve pooled investments in income-producing real estate. Sharia-compliant REITs ensure the properties and their financing methods are permissible, avoiding interest-based mortgages and prohibited business activities within the properties. Key features: Pureoptical.co.uk Review

  • Tangible Assets: Investment in physical properties.
  • Rental Income: Returns primarily from rent, which is permissible.
  • Diversification: Access to large real estate portfolios without direct ownership.
  • Average Price: Investment typically via shares, price varies per REIT.
  • Pros: Diversification, potential for steady income, ownership of real assets.
  • Cons: Market fluctuations can impact value, limited Sharia-compliant options in some markets.

• Gold and Silver as Physical Assets: Investing in physical gold or silver bullion is a classic method of wealth preservation and a permissible store of value in Islam, provided the transaction involves immediate exchange and physical possession. This avoids the speculative nature of paper gold or silver contracts. Key features:

  

  • Tangible Asset: Real, physical commodity.
  • Inflation Hedge: Often retains value during economic instability.
  • Global Acceptability: Universally recognised.
  • Average Price: Market price of gold/silver plus a small premium for fabrication and delivery.
  • Pros: Wealth preservation, protection against currency depreciation, no Riba.
  • Cons: Storage costs, insurance needs, price volatility in the short term, no income generation.

• Direct Investment in Small Businesses: This involves personally investing in or partnering with a small business, adhering to Islamic partnership principles (Mudarabah or Musharakah). The investment is based on profit-and-loss sharing, where all parties bear risk and reward proportionally. Key features:

  • Active Involvement (optional): Opportunity to contribute skills and expertise.
  • Risk & Reward Sharing: Direct alignment with Islamic finance principles.
  • Supporting Real Economy: Fosters local growth and employment.
  • Average Price: Highly variable, depends on the business and investment terms.
  • Pros: Deeply aligns with Islamic finance, high potential for impact and returns if successful.
  • Cons: High risk, requires significant due diligence, illiquid, management effort if actively involved.

• Sustainable and Ethical Investment Portfolios: These are managed portfolios that integrate Environmental, Social, and Governance (ESG) factors into investment decisions. While not exclusively Islamic, many ESG criteria overlap with Sharia principles by avoiding industries deemed harmful or unethical. It’s vital to scrutinise the specific holdings to ensure no Riba-based instruments or prohibited sectors are included. Key features:

  • Broad Ethical Focus: Covers environmental protection, social justice, and good governance.
  • Diversification: Can invest across various asset classes and sectors.
  • Professional Management: Managed by experts in ethical investing.
  • Average Price: Management fees similar to conventional funds (0.5% – 2%).
  • Pros: Positive societal impact, generally stable long-term returns, professional oversight.
  • Cons: May still include some financial instruments that are not strictly Sharia-compliant (e.g., bonds if not sukuk), requires careful review of underlying assets.

The Impermissible Nature of Forex and CFD Trading

Forex (Foreign Exchange) and CFDs (Contracts for Difference) are widely traded financial instruments, but their structure and operational mechanisms inherently clash with fundamental Islamic financial principles. For any Muslim seeking to engage in financial transactions, understanding these prohibitions is paramount to ensuring their earnings and investments remain permissible (Halal). The core issues revolve around Riba (interest), Gharar (excessive uncertainty), and Maysir (gambling). Emergeacademy.co.uk Review

Riba: The Forbidden Element of Interest

Riba, or interest, is unequivocally prohibited in Islam. It refers to any predetermined, fixed return on a loan or an exchange of money for money with a delay. In the context of Forex and CFDs, Riba manifests in several ways:

• Overnight Swaps/Rollover Fees: When a Forex or CFD position is held overnight, brokers typically charge or pay a “swap” or “rollover” fee. This fee is essentially an interest payment calculated based on the interest rate differential between the two currencies in a pair. If you hold a long position in a currency with a higher interest rate and short a currency with a lower interest rate, you might earn a positive swap. Conversely, if the rates are reversed, you pay a negative swap. This direct involvement with interest makes overnight positions haram.
• Leverage as an Interest-Bearing Loan: The very mechanism of leverage in Forex and CFD trading often involves an implicit interest-bearing loan from the broker. When you trade on margin, you are effectively borrowing funds from the broker to control a larger position than your capital allows. While brokers may not explicitly charge daily interest on the “borrowed” amount for intra-day trades, the potential for rollover fees (which are interest) and the underlying concept of profiting from borrowed funds without a genuine productive partnership makes it problematic. The Council of Islamic Fiqh Academy has issued rulings condemning leveraged trading due to its Riba aspect.

Gharar: Excessive Uncertainty and Ambiguity

Gharar refers to excessive uncertainty, ambiguity, or deception in a contract. Islamic finance promotes clarity and transparency in transactions, discouraging agreements where the outcome is unknown or the subject matter is not clearly defined. Forex and CFDs exhibit high levels of Gharar:

• Lack of Tangible Asset Exchange: In Forex and CFD trading, there is no physical exchange or ownership of the underlying asset (e.g., actual currency, barrels of oil, or company shares). Traders are merely speculating on price movements. This detachment from real assets is a significant source of Gharar.
• Highly Speculative Nature: The extremely volatile and unpredictable nature of currency and commodity markets, combined with the rapid execution of trades, means that the outcome is highly uncertain and often resembles a zero-sum game. One party’s gain often comes directly from another’s loss, without any underlying productive activity or genuine asset transfer benefiting society.
• Counterparty Risk and Broker Models: Depending on the broker’s model (e.g., B-book brokers), the broker might take the opposite side of a client’s trade. This creates a conflict of interest, as the broker profits when the client loses, contributing to a lack of transparency and an element of Gharar.

Maysir: The Prohibited Act of Gambling

Maysir, or gambling, is forbidden in Islam. It is defined as a game or transaction where wealth is acquired by chance, with no genuine productive effort, and where there is a win-lose outcome for the participants. Forex and CFD trading, particularly short-term speculative trading, bears a strong resemblance to gambling:

• Zero-Sum Game: In many instances, the financial markets, especially with highly leveraged derivatives, function as a zero-sum game. For every winner, there must be a loser. This does not contribute to the overall economic pie but merely redistributes wealth based on price speculation.
• Lack of Productive Activity: Unlike legitimate business ventures where goods are produced, services are rendered, or real assets are developed, speculative trading on price movements alone does not create tangible value for society. It is pure speculation on future prices, similar to betting.
• Emotional and Psychological Impact: The allure of quick profits in highly leveraged trading often leads to addictive behaviour, excessive risk-taking, and significant emotional distress when losses occur. This psychological aspect further aligns it with the negative consequences associated with gambling.

Why Avoid Platforms like ICM Capital?

Given the inherent presence of Riba, Gharar, and Maysir in Forex and CFD trading, platforms like ICM Capital, despite their professional appearance and regulatory adherence (from a conventional standpoint), offer services that are impermissible for Muslims. While they may highlight features like “tight spreads” or “fast execution,” these merely enhance the efficiency of transactions that are fundamentally flawed under Islamic law. It’s crucial for individuals to understand that any platform facilitating these types of leveraged, speculative, and interest-based derivative trades should be avoided. The focus should instead be on ethical investments that contribute to real economic growth, uphold justice, and distribute risk and reward fairly.

ICMcapital.co.uk Pros & Cons

When evaluating icmcapital.co.uk, it’s essential to consider its functionalities from a general user perspective, divorced from the ethical considerations that are paramount for a Muslim audience. This allows for a balanced view of what the platform offers, while simultaneously highlighting its inherent drawbacks from an Islamic perspective. Obaguk.co.uk Review

Cons (From an Islamic Ethical Perspective)

For a Muslim, the “cons” of using icmcapital.co.uk are fundamental and absolute, rendering any potential “pros” irrelevant. The entire premise of the platform’s core offerings is impermissible.

• Involvement in Riba (Interest): The most significant and unequivocal con. Forex and CFD trading, especially with leverage, inherently involves Riba through overnight swap fees and the concept of borrowing funds for magnified positions. This is strictly prohibited in Islam. Any profit derived from such transactions is considered ill-gotten gain.
• Excessive Gharar (Uncertainty/Speculation): The very nature of CFDs and Forex trading is highly speculative. There’s no physical exchange of goods or services, only contracts based on price movements. This high degree of uncertainty regarding the outcome, combined with the lack of tangible asset ownership, makes it problematic under Islamic law.
• Maysir (Gambling): The short-term, high-leverage trading of these instruments often devolves into a zero-sum game, where gains for one trader come directly from losses for another. This mirrors the characteristics of gambling, which is explicitly forbidden in Islam due to its potential for addiction, financial ruin, and lack of productive economic contribution.
• High Risk of Capital Loss: While stated as a regulatory warning, it’s a critical con from an ethical standpoint. The inherent volatility and leverage can lead to rapid and substantial financial losses, which can have devastating consequences for individuals and families, contrary to Islamic principles of wealth preservation and responsible financial management. The website explicitly states, “CFDs and Spot FX are complex instruments and come with a high risk of losing money rapidly due to leverage.”
• Lack of Tangible Economic Benefit: Unlike investments in real businesses, agriculture, or ethical industries, speculative trading on platforms like ICM Capital does not contribute to the production of goods, provision of services, or real economic growth. It’s a transfer of wealth through price fluctuations, which offers no benefit to society.

Pros (From a Conventional, Non-Islamic Perspective)

If one were to disregard the Islamic prohibitions, ICM Capital presents several features that might appeal to a conventional professional trader:

• Established Presence: The company has been “leading investment house since 2009,” indicating over a decade of operation in the financial markets. This longevity can build trust among conventional traders.
• Regulatory Compliance (Implied): While specific regulators aren’t listed on the homepage snippets, the presence of a “Regulation” link is crucial. Assuming it points to legitimate regulatory bodies (e.g., FCA in the UK), this offers a layer of protection and oversight for conventional clients.
• Competitive Trading Conditions: The website highlights “Very Tight Spreads,” “ECN Spreads from 0.0 Pips,” and “Ultra-fast Execution with no Re-quotes.” These features are highly sought after by active traders as they can reduce trading costs and improve execution quality.
• Deep Liquidity: “Liquidity from Tier-1 Banks” is a significant advantage, meaning trades can be executed quickly and at the desired prices, even for large volumes, reducing slippage.
• Variety of Trading Products: Offering “Forex, Commodities & CFDs in One Account” provides convenience and diversification options for traders looking to access different markets.
• Advanced Trading Platforms: Support for “METATRADER 4 (MT4) FOR PC, IPHONE, ANDROID” is a strong point. MT4 is a globally recognised and highly popular trading platform known for its charting tools, technical indicators, and automated trading capabilities.
• Award-Winning Client Services: The claim of an “Award-winning Client Services Team*” and awards like “Best Forex Customer Service Broker UK 2023” suggest a commitment to customer support, which is vital in the fast-paced trading environment.
• Market Leading Insurance: The mention of “Civil Liability Insurance cover up to £5,000,000**” offers a significant level of reassurance for clients regarding the safety of their funds, though this specific detail needs to be verified on the linked page.
• Educational Tools and Resources: The provision of an “Economic Calendar,” “Trading Central Reports,” “Live News SMS,” and a “FREE DAILY MARKET REPORT” indicates an effort to provide traders with analytical tools and market insights.
• Segregated Client Accounts: “Ultimate Safety of Clients’ Funds Segregated Client Accounts” is a standard but crucial safety measure, meaning client funds are held separately from the company’s operational funds, offering protection in case of company insolvency.

In summary, while ICM Capital offers a robust and feature-rich platform for conventional Forex and CFD trading, its core services are incompatible with Islamic financial ethics due to the involvement of Riba, Gharar, and Maysir. Therefore, for a Muslim, the “cons” unequivocally outweigh any conventional “pros.”

How to Avoid Impermissible Financial Activities

Avoiding impermissible financial activities, especially in the complex world of modern finance, requires diligence and a clear understanding of Islamic principles. For Muslims, the goal is to ensure that all financial dealings are free from Riba (interest), Gharar (excessive uncertainty), and Maysir (gambling). This isn’t just about avoiding obvious prohibitions, but also understanding the nuances of various financial products and services.

Understand the Core Prohibitions

Before engaging in any financial transaction, it’s crucial to solidify your understanding of the three main prohibitions: Ardent-cleaning.co.uk Review

• Riba (Interest): Any predetermined increment on a loan, or an unequal exchange of money for money with a delay. This includes interest earned on savings accounts, interest paid on conventional loans (mortgages, credit cards), and hidden interest in complex financial instruments.
• Gharar (Excessive Uncertainty): Transactions where the outcome is highly uncertain, the subject matter is unknown, or there’s a significant element of ambiguity that could lead to dispute or exploitation. This often applies to speculative derivatives and contracts where there’s no clear asset exchange.
• Maysir (Gambling): Any activity where wealth is acquired purely by chance, without genuine effort, and where one party wins at the expense of another in a zero-sum game. This includes lotteries, betting, and highly speculative trading.

Identify Key Red Flags in Financial Products

When assessing any financial product or service, look out for these red flags:

• Leverage/Margin Trading: If a product offers high leverage or margin trading, it almost certainly involves Riba, as you’re effectively borrowing money to magnify your position. Examples include Forex, CFDs, and options trading on margin.
• Overnight Fees/Swaps: For trading platforms, inquire about “overnight fees” or “swaps.” If these exist and are based on interest rate differentials, the activity is problematic.
• Guaranteed Fixed Returns on Deposits: While some investment schemes offer fixed returns, if these are derived from loaning out your money at interest, it’s Riba. Halal investments yield returns based on profit-sharing from real economic activity.
• Lack of Tangible Asset Exchange: If you’re trading a contract or a derivative without ever intending or being able to take physical possession of the underlying asset (e.g., actual barrels of oil, bushels of wheat, or company shares), it’s a strong indicator of Gharar and often Maysir.
• High Volatility with Short-Term Speculation: Products marketed for very short-term, rapid trading based purely on price movements (day trading) often fall under Maysir due to their speculative nature and lack of productive basis.
• Conventional Insurance Policies: Most conventional insurance policies involve elements of Riba and Gharar. Seek Takaful (Islamic cooperative insurance) alternatives.
• Conventional Loans and Credit Cards: These are almost always interest-based. Look for Islamic home financing (Murabaha, Musharakah Mutanaqisah) or interest-free loans (Qard Hasan) where available.

Research and Seek Sharia-Compliant Alternatives

The best way to avoid impermissible activities is to actively seek out and utilise Sharia-compliant alternatives. The global Islamic finance industry has grown significantly, offering various products that adhere to ethical principles.

• Islamic Banks and Financial Institutions: These institutions are specifically structured to operate without Riba and adhere to Sharia principles in all their offerings, from savings accounts to financing.
• Sharia-Compliant Investment Funds: These funds screen investments to ensure they are free from prohibited industries (e.g., alcohol, tobacco, gambling, conventional finance, pornography) and do not deal in Riba-based instruments. They are overseen by a Sharia board.
• Sukuk (Islamic Bonds): Instead of interest-bearing bonds, Sukuk represent ownership in tangible assets or specific projects, generating returns from the profits or rentals of those assets.
• Takaful (Islamic Insurance): A cooperative system where participants contribute to a common fund, and claims are paid out from this fund. Any surplus is often shared among participants, avoiding the Riba and Gharar of conventional insurance.
• Halal Equity Investing: Directly investing in shares of companies that operate in permissible sectors, have low debt, and generate their primary income from halal activities. This requires due diligence or using a Sharia-screening service.
• Islamic Mortgages/Home Financing: Products like Murabaha (cost-plus financing) or Musharakah Mutanaqisah (diminishing partnership) allow for home ownership without engaging in interest.

Consult Knowledgeable Scholars

If you are unsure about the permissibility of a particular financial product or transaction, always consult with knowledgeable Islamic scholars or institutions specialising in Islamic finance. They can provide authoritative guidance based on contemporary Fiqh (Islamic jurisprudence). Many Islamic financial institutions have their own Sharia supervisory boards whose rulings provide a reliable source of information.

By applying these principles and exercising caution, individuals can navigate the financial landscape responsibly, ensuring their wealth is acquired and managed in a way that is pleasing to Allah and beneficial for both themselves and society.

ICMcapital.co.uk Account Types & Eligibility

ICM Capital explicitly states that its services are intended for “Professional Clients Only.” This is a critical distinction that dictates who can even open an account on their platform. This focus on professional clients suggests that the platform caters to experienced traders who understand the inherent risks of leveraged trading and derivative products like Forex and CFDs. It also implies that they might not offer the same level of regulatory protection or simplified user experience typically provided to retail clients. Peeli.co.uk Review

Professional Client Criteria

For a financial institution in the UK (regulated by the FCA), the criteria for classifying a client as “professional” are stringent and specific. These criteria typically involve:

• Experience in the Financial Sector: The client must have carried out transactions of significant size (e.g., 10 transactions per quarter over the past four quarters) on the relevant market.
• Size of Financial Portfolio: The client must have a financial instrument portfolio exceeding a certain value (e.g., €500,000, or approximately £430,000). This includes cash deposits and financial investments.
• Relevant Professional Experience: The client must work or have worked in the financial sector for at least one year in a professional position which requires knowledge of the transactions or services envisaged.

Meeting at least two out of these three criteria usually qualifies an individual as a professional client. The statement “Check eligibility” on icmcapital.co.uk likely directs potential clients to a detailed page outlining these specific requirements.

Implications of Being a “Professional Client”

While a conventional broker might view this as a mark of sophistication, for the client, it carries significant implications, particularly regarding regulatory protections:

• Reduced Regulatory Protections: Professional clients typically waive certain protections afforded to retail clients, such as:
  • Negative Balance Protection: While some brokers voluntarily offer it, it’s not a regulatory requirement for professional clients. This means you could lose more than your deposited capital.
  • Investor Compensation Scheme (ICS) Limits: While professional clients may still be covered by compensation schemes (like FSCS in the UK up to £85,000), the extent of coverage might differ or be less comprehensive than for retail clients in specific scenarios.
  • Marketing Restrictions: Professional clients may receive more aggressive marketing of complex products.
  • Risk Warnings: Professional clients are assumed to understand the risks and may not receive as frequent or explicit risk warnings as retail clients.
  • Leverage Limits: Professional clients are usually granted much higher leverage than retail clients (e.g., 1:200 for professionals vs. 1:30 for retail under ESMA regulations), significantly increasing potential losses.

Account Types Mentioned

The website mentions “Account Type” and “ICM Direct.” While specifics would be on the linked pages, “ICM Direct” likely refers to a specific account model, possibly an ECN (Electronic Communication Network) account, given the emphasis on “ECN Spreads from 0.0 Pips.” ECN accounts are typically favoured by professional traders seeking direct market access and tighter spreads.

Ethical (Islamic) Perspective on Account Types

Regardless of the account type or eligibility criteria, the ethical prohibitions remain. Whether one is a “professional” or “retail” client, engaging in transactions that involve Riba, Gharar, and Maysir is impermissible in Islam. The increased leverage and reduced protections for “professional clients” only amplify the risks associated with an already prohibited activity, potentially leading to greater financial ruin. Therefore, even if an individual qualifies as a professional client, from an Islamic standpoint, it is still crucial to abstain from such platforms. Alcoengineering.co.uk Review

Understanding the Trading Products Offered by ICM Capital

ICM Capital’s primary offerings revolve around Forex, CFDs (Contracts for Difference), and Commodities. These are popular instruments in global financial markets, but each carries specific characteristics and risks, particularly when viewed through the lens of Islamic finance.

Forex (Foreign Exchange)

Forex trading involves the exchange of one currency for another. It is the largest and most liquid financial market globally. Traders speculate on the rise or fall of exchange rates between currency pairs (e.g., EUR/USD, GBP/JPY).

• How it Works (Conventional): When you trade Forex on a platform like ICM Capital, you are typically not taking physical delivery of the currencies. Instead, you are entering into a contract to exchange currencies at a future date or to profit from the difference in their values. This is almost always done on leverage.
• Ethical Issues (Islamic):
  • Riba (Interest): The primary concern is the overnight swap fees, which are interest-based. Even if one tries to avoid holding positions overnight, the inherent leverage often functions as an interest-bearing loan from the broker.
  • Gharar (Uncertainty): The rapid and often unpredictable fluctuations in currency values, combined with the lack of physical exchange of currencies, introduces significant uncertainty and risk.
  • Maysir (Gambling): Short-term Forex trading often becomes a zero-sum game of speculation, akin to gambling, rather than a genuine exchange for productive purposes.

CFDs (Contracts for Difference)

CFDs are complex financial instruments that allow traders to speculate on the price movements of various underlying assets without actually owning them. These assets can include stocks, indices, commodities, and even cryptocurrencies (though not explicitly mentioned for ICM Capital on the homepage).

• How it Works (Conventional): When you trade a CFD, you enter into an agreement with the broker to exchange the difference in the price of an asset from the time the contract is opened until it is closed. If the price moves in your favour, you gain; if it moves against you, you lose. CFDs are almost always traded with high leverage.
• Ethical Issues (Islamic): CFDs embody significant issues from an Islamic perspective:
  • Riba (Interest): Like Forex, CFDs involve overnight financing charges (interest) for leveraged positions.
  • Gharar (Excessive Uncertainty): The absence of ownership of the underlying asset, coupled with the highly leveraged and speculative nature, makes CFDs prone to excessive uncertainty and risk. The contract itself is based on a future difference, making it inherently uncertain.
  • Maysir (Gambling): The high leverage and rapid price movements turn CFD trading into a highly speculative activity, often driven by pure chance rather than fundamental analysis or productive investment. It’s a bet on price direction, not an investment in a real asset.
  • Lack of Qabdh (Possession): Islamic law requires possession (Qabdh) of the underlying asset in many types of transactions to ensure validity and prevent speculation. CFDs explicitly bypass this.

Commodities

Commodities trading involves speculating on the price movements of raw materials such as oil, gold, silver, natural gas, agricultural products (e.g., wheat, corn), and precious metals.

• How it Works (Conventional via ICM Capital): On a platform like ICM Capital, you are typically trading commodity CFDs, not taking physical delivery of the commodities. This means the ethical issues of CFDs apply here as well. While some commodity markets do involve physical delivery (e.g., futures contracts for large institutions), retail platforms almost exclusively offer CFDs.
• Ethical Issues (Islamic):
  • Commodity CFDs: When commodities are traded as CFDs, they inherit all the prohibitions associated with CFDs (Riba, Gharar, Maysir) due to the lack of ownership and leveraged, speculative nature.
  • Physical Commodity Trading (Permissible with conditions): Trading physical commodities (e.g., buying actual gold bullion) is permissible in Islam, provided it adheres to strict conditions:
    • Immediate Qabdh (Possession): The buyer must take immediate or constructive possession of the commodity.
    • No Riba: The transaction must be free from interest.
    • No Gharar: The terms of the trade must be clear, and the commodity must be known and deliverable.
  • Distinction is Key: It is vital to distinguish between permissible physical commodity trading and impermissible commodity CFD trading. ICM Capital primarily offers the latter to its retail/professional clients.

Other Trading Products (Implied)

The website also mentions “US Stocks” and “Indices” under “Online Quotes.” This strongly implies that ICM Capital offers CFDs on these instruments as well, rather than direct stock ownership. Therefore, the same ethical concerns surrounding CFDs would apply to these products. Cookiejarstudio.co.uk Review

In conclusion, while the trading products offered by ICM Capital are standard in the conventional financial world, their structure and operational mechanisms (especially leveraged CFD trading) make them fundamentally incompatible with Islamic financial principles. For a Muslim, engaging in such activities is considered impermissible, regardless of the potential for profit or the platform’s features.

ICMcapital.co.uk Trading Tools & Platforms

ICM Capital provides its clients with a range of trading tools and platforms designed to facilitate market analysis, trade execution, and account management. The availability of robust tools is often a key factor for traders, as it directly impacts their ability to make informed decisions and execute trades efficiently.

Trading Platforms

The core of ICM Capital’s trading environment is built around the highly popular and widely recognised MetaTrader 4 (MT4) platform. This is a significant advantage for conventional traders, as MT4 is known for its reliability, extensive features, and user-friendly interface.

• MT4 Desktop: This is the full-featured version of MT4, offering advanced charting capabilities, a wide array of technical indicators, and the ability to use Expert Advisors (EAs) for automated trading. Professional traders often prefer the desktop version for its comprehensive functionality and stability.
• MT4 For Mac: Catering to Apple users, this ensures that Mac owners can also access the powerful MT4 platform without needing to run Windows emulators.
• MT4 iPhone/iPad: Mobile trading is crucial in today’s fast-paced markets. The MT4 mobile apps allow traders to monitor their positions, execute trades, and perform basic analysis on the go, ensuring they can react quickly to market movements.
• MT4 Android: Similarly, the Android version of MT4 provides full mobile trading capabilities for users of Android smartphones and tablets.

The choice of MT4 across multiple devices reflects ICM Capital’s commitment to providing accessible and powerful trading solutions, which is a common expectation among serious traders.

Trading Tools and Resources

Beyond the trading platforms, ICM Capital offers several supplementary tools and resources to aid traders in their decision-making process: Youvebeencleaned.co.uk Review

• Economic Calendar: This tool provides a schedule of important economic events and data releases (e.g., GDP figures, inflation reports, interest rate decisions) that can significantly impact financial markets. Traders use it to anticipate market volatility and adjust their strategies. For example, knowing the release of the UK CPI (Consumer Price Index) data can inform decisions on GBP pairs.
• Trading Central: This is a third-party analytical service that provides professional technical analysis, market insights, and trading signals. It can be a valuable resource for traders looking for expert opinions and validated trading ideas. Trading Central often covers various asset classes including Forex, commodities, and indices.
• Mobile tools: The website mentions “Mobile tools” and provides a link to a Google Play Store app (“ICM Access”). This suggests a dedicated mobile application beyond just the MT4 mobile platforms, likely for account management, funding, or specific market news.
• Live News SMS: Receiving market news updates via SMS can be crucial for traders who need immediate alerts on significant market-moving events, even when they are away from their screens.
• Market News & Events: Dedicated sections on the website for “Market News” and “Events” provide regular updates and analyses relevant to the financial markets. This includes corporate news from ICM Capital itself and broader market developments.
• FREE DAILY MARKET REPORT: Subscribing to this report offers key support and resistance levels, market summaries, and charts, providing daily insights to help traders plan their strategies.

Ethical (Islamic) Perspective on Tools and Platforms

While these tools and platforms are technologically advanced and highly functional, their utility in an Islamic context is severely limited. The tools themselves are neutral, but their application within the context of impermissible trading activities makes them problematic. For a Muslim, using these sophisticated charting tools to speculate on interest-based CFDs or highly uncertain Forex transactions would still render the entire activity haram. It’s akin to having the best tools for building something forbidden – the tools don’t make the forbidden act permissible. Therefore, while ICM Capital offers a comprehensive suite for conventional traders, these features do not mitigate the fundamental ethical issues for a Muslim audience.

Corporate Social Responsibility (CSR) & Sponsorships

ICM Capital’s website dedicates sections to “Corporate Social Responsibility (CSR)” and “Sponsorships.” In the conventional business world, these initiatives are seen as positive indicators of a company’s commitment beyond just profit generation, potentially enhancing brand image and fostering trust. However, for a Muslim evaluating the ethical stance of a company, these aspects must be weighed against the fundamental nature of its core business operations.

Corporate Social Responsibility (CSR)

The existence of a “Corporate Social Responsibility (CSR)” section suggests that ICM Capital engages in activities aimed at contributing positively to society and operating in an ethical and sustainable manner. Typically, CSR initiatives include:

• Environmental Responsibility: Efforts to reduce carbon footprint, conserve resources, and promote sustainable practices.
• Philanthropy: Charitable donations, community development projects, or support for social causes.
• Ethical Labour Practices: Ensuring fair wages, safe working conditions, and promoting diversity and inclusion within the company.
• Responsible Sourcing: Ensuring that supply chains are ethical and free from exploitation.

While the specific details of ICM Capital’s CSR initiatives would be on the linked page, the very presence of this section indicates an awareness of broader societal impact. However, the effectiveness and true ethical value of a company’s CSR efforts are often scrutinised in relation to its primary source of income. If the core business generates income through means considered impermissible (e.g., Riba, gambling), then any CSR initiatives, while seemingly positive, do not purify the primary earnings from an Islamic perspective. It’s a common ethical debate: can a company doing something ethically questionable at its core truly be “responsible” through its peripheral activities?

Sponsorships

ICM Capital highlights its “Sponsorships,” with examples provided on the homepage: Eastengineering.co.uk Review

• ICM and Swisspod Technologies Partnership to Innovate The Future of Hyperloop: This high-profile partnership with a company pioneering Hyperloop technology suggests a significant investment in cutting-edge innovation and future transportation solutions. Such sponsorships can elevate a company’s profile and demonstrate its commitment to technological advancement.
• ICM Joins as Gold Sponsors of Finance Magnates Africa Summit 2023: Sponsoring industry-specific events like the Finance Magnates Summit indicates a strong presence within the financial services sector and a commitment to networking and thought leadership in the trading community.
• ICM Announced as Official Partner of France SailGP Team for 2023: Sports sponsorships, particularly in high-speed, dynamic events like SailGP, are often used to enhance brand visibility and associate the company with attributes like speed, precision, and performance. This is a common marketing strategy to reach a broader audience.

These sponsorships demonstrate ICM Capital’s financial capacity and marketing prowess. They contribute to brand recognition and position the company as a significant player in the global financial landscape.

Ethical (Islamic) Perspective on CSR and Sponsorships

From an Islamic perspective, while supporting positive initiatives and contributing to technological advancements or sports can be laudable in themselves, these actions do not legitimise or purify income derived from impermissible sources. If the core business of ICM Capital (Forex and CFD trading with Riba and Gharar) is considered haram, then the funds used for CSR and sponsorships are ultimately generated from impermissible means.

In Islam, the source of wealth is paramount. Wealth acquired through Riba or Maysir is tainted, and spending it on charitable causes or sponsorships, while good actions in isolation, does not cleanse the original sin of acquiring it. Muslims are encouraged to earn wealth through halal means (e.g., trade, legitimate services, productive investments) and then spend from that halal wealth on charity and beneficial causes. Therefore, while ICM Capital’s CSR and sponsorship activities might project a positive conventional image, they do not alleviate the fundamental ethical concerns for a Muslim audience.

Market Leading Insurance & Safety of Clients’ Funds

ICM Capital places a strong emphasis on the security of client funds, highlighting “Ultimate Safety of Clients’ Funds Segregated Client Accounts” and “Market Leading Insurance Civil Liability Insurance cover up to £5,000,000**”. These features are critical for building trust in the financial industry, especially for platforms dealing with high-risk leveraged products.

Segregated Client Accounts

The concept of “Segregated Client Accounts” is a standard regulatory requirement for legitimate financial brokers. Centrallyheated.co.uk Review

• How it Works: This means that clients’ funds are held in separate bank accounts from the broker’s operational funds. These accounts are usually maintained with reputable, top-tier banks. The purpose is to protect client money in the event of the broker’s insolvency or bankruptcy.
• Importance: If a broker goes out of business, client funds in segregated accounts are theoretically protected from being used to pay off the broker’s creditors. They remain the property of the clients and can be returned to them. This is a vital safeguard against commingling of funds and misuses.
• Regulatory Requirement: Most reputable financial regulators, including the FCA in the UK (if ICM Capital is regulated by them), mandate segregated client accounts. This ensures that clients’ money is not part of the firm’s assets and cannot be claimed by general creditors.

Market Leading Insurance (Civil Liability Insurance)

The claim of “Market Leading Insurance Civil Liability Insurance cover up to £5,000,000**” is a significant additional layer of protection.

• How it Works: Civil liability insurance, in this context, would typically protect clients against financial losses resulting from the broker’s errors, omissions, negligence, or fraud. For example, if there was a system error leading to incorrect trade execution or a data breach, this insurance could potentially cover the resulting client losses up to the specified amount.
• Coverage Extent: The £5,000,000 coverage is substantial and aims to provide a high level of reassurance to clients. This goes beyond standard investor compensation schemes (like the FSCS in the UK, which covers up to £85,000 per person per firm for eligible claims). It suggests that ICM Capital is investing in robust protection for its clients beyond the minimum regulatory requirements.
• Verification: While impressive, it is always crucial for clients to verify the specifics of such insurance policies, including the insurer, the exact scope of coverage, and the conditions under which claims can be made. The asterisk “**” on the website indicates that more details are likely available on a linked page.

Ethical (Islamic) Perspective on Safety Measures

From an Islamic perspective, while the presence of segregated accounts and high-level insurance is laudable in terms of financial prudence and client protection, these measures do not purify the underlying impermissible nature of the trading activities themselves.

• Protecting Impermissible Gains: Segregated accounts and insurance primarily protect the funds that clients deposit and potentially the profits they generate. If these funds are intended for or derived from transactions involving Riba, Gharar, or Maysir, then protecting them, while commercially sound, does not make the original source of the funds or the trading activity permissible.
• Focus on Lawful Earning: Islamic finance places paramount importance on the source of income. Muslims are obligated to earn wealth through lawful means, avoiding prohibited transactions. While safety measures protect against external risks (broker insolvency, errors), they cannot cleanse the inherent ethical flaws of the financial products being traded.
• Alternatives: For Muslims, the focus should be on engaging with truly Sharia-compliant financial institutions that offer ethical investments and products, where the very structure of the offering is permissible from the outset, thus requiring no “purification” of earnings or reliance on insurance to cover impermissible gains.

In essence, while ICM Capital offers strong safeguards for client funds from a conventional risk management perspective, these measures do not resolve the fundamental conflict with Islamic financial principles regarding the impermissible nature of Forex and CFD trading.

FAQ

What is icmcapital.co.uk?

ICM Capital (icmcapital.co.uk) is an online trading platform based in the UK that offers trading services for Forex, CFDs (Contracts for Difference), and Commodities. It primarily targets “Professional Clients Only” and provides access to markets through the MetaTrader 4 platform.

Is icmcapital.co.uk regulated?

The website indicates a “Regulation” section, which strongly suggests that ICM Capital operates under relevant financial regulatory bodies. For a UK-based company, this would typically imply regulation by the Financial Conduct Authority (FCA). Idealcleaningcentre.co.uk Review

Is Forex trading permissible in Islam?

No, Forex trading as offered by platforms like ICM Capital (involving leverage and overnight swaps) is generally not permissible (haram) in Islam due to the inherent presence of Riba (interest through swaps), excessive Gharar (uncertainty), and Maysir (gambling/speculation).

Are CFDs permissible in Islam?

No, CFDs (Contracts for Difference) are generally not permissible (haram) in Islam. They involve Riba (interest on leveraged positions), excessive Gharar (speculation without ownership of the underlying asset), and Maysir (gambling).

Is commodity trading permissible in Islam?

Trading physical commodities with immediate possession and no interest is permissible. However, trading commodities as CFDs (as offered by ICM Capital) is not permissible (haram) for the same reasons as other CFDs: Riba, Gharar, and Maysir.

Does icmcapital.co.uk offer Sharia-compliant accounts?

Based on the website’s description of its core services (Forex, CFDs, and leveraged trading), it does not appear to offer Sharia-compliant accounts. The very nature of these products contradicts Islamic financial principles.

What are the main ethical issues with icmcapital.co.uk from an Islamic perspective?

The main ethical issues are the involvement in Riba (interest) through leveraged trading and overnight swaps, Gharar (excessive uncertainty) due to the speculative nature and lack of tangible asset exchange in CFDs/Forex, and Maysir (gambling) as short-term trading often becomes a zero-sum game of speculation. Myraindrop.co.uk Review

What are the alternatives to icmcapital.co.uk for a Muslim?

Ethical alternatives include: Islamic Finance & Investment Funds, Ethical Savings Accounts, Crowdfunding Platforms for Ethical Businesses, Sharia-compliant Real Estate Investment Trusts (REITs), physical Gold and Silver investments, direct investment in small businesses, and Sustainable and Ethical Investment Portfolios (after careful screening).

Is ICM Capital suitable for beginners?

No, ICM Capital explicitly states it’s for “Professional Clients Only,” meaning it is not suitable for beginners or retail traders. Professional client status comes with reduced regulatory protections and requires significant trading experience and financial portfolios.

How safe are funds with icmcapital.co.uk?

ICM Capital states it uses “Segregated Client Accounts” and offers “Civil Liability Insurance cover up to £5,000,000.” These measures are designed to protect client funds in case of broker insolvency or errors, and are strong indicators of security from a conventional perspective.

What trading platforms does icmcapital.co.uk offer?

ICM Capital primarily offers the MetaTrader 4 (MT4) platform for Desktop, Mac, iPhone/iPad, and Android devices.

Does ICM Capital provide any trading tools or educational resources?

Yes, ICM Capital provides an Economic Calendar, Trading Central analysis, Live News SMS, Market News, Events, and a Free Daily Market Report. Timothytaylor.co.uk Review

What are the key features highlighted by icmcapital.co.uk?

Key features highlighted include Very Tight Spreads (ECN Spreads from 0.0 Pips), Ultra-fast Execution, Deep Liquidity from Tier-1 Banks, Leveraged Trading (up to 1:200), a variety of products, award-winning client services, and market-leading insurance.

Does icmcapital.co.uk offer negative balance protection?

While not explicitly stated for “Professional Clients Only” on the homepage, retail clients regulated under ESMA typically receive negative balance protection. However, professional clients often waive this protection, meaning they could potentially lose more than their deposited capital.

How can I contact ICM Capital’s support?

You can contact ICM Capital via phone at UK +44 207 634 9770, email at [email protected], or via live chat and callback request forms on their website.

What kind of news and updates does icmcapital.co.uk provide?

ICM Capital provides Company News, Market News, Events, and SMS News, covering topics like partnerships, sponsorships, and general market developments.

What is Corporate Social Responsibility (CSR) in the context of ICM Capital?

ICM Capital has a CSR section, indicating its engagement in activities that aim to contribute positively to society, such as environmental initiatives, philanthropy, or ethical labour practices. However, from an Islamic perspective, such initiatives do not purify income derived from impermissible sources. Hatchers.co.uk Review

Does ICM Capital have any awards?

Yes, ICM Capital prominently displays several awards, including “Best Forex Customer Service Broker UK 2023,” “Best Forex Broker Asia 2023,” and “Excellent Trade Executions Middle East 2023.”

Can I open a demo account with ICM Capital?

The website mentions “Free ECN demo available with ICM Direct,” suggesting that prospective clients can open a demo account to try out the platform before committing real funds.

Why does ICM Capital focus on “Professional Clients Only”?

Focusing on “Professional Clients Only” allows ICM Capital to offer higher leverage (e.g., 1:200) and operate with fewer regulatory restrictions that apply to retail clients under regulations like ESMA, who typically face leverage limits of 1:30.

0.0 0.0 out of 5 stars (based on 0 reviews) Excellent0% Very good0% Average0% Poor0% Terrible0% There are no reviews yet. Be the first one to write one. Your review Your overall rating Select a Rating5 Stars4 Stars3 Stars2 Stars1 Star Title of your review Your review Your name Your email This review is based on my own experience and is my genuine opinion. ​ Submit Review

Amazon.com: Check Amazon for Icmcapital.co.uk Review Latest Discussions & Reviews: