The Perils of “Buy Now Pay Later” and Riba in Islam

Moramode.com’s prominent offering of “Buy Now Pay Later” (BNPL) options via Klarna, ClearPay, and PayPal Credit is a critical point of concern from an Islamic financial perspective. The prohibition of riba (interest) is one of the most emphasized commandments in Islamic economics, making these financing methods highly problematic.

Read more about moramode.com:
Moramode.com Review & Ethical Considerations
Understanding the Ethical Landscape of Wigs in Islam

Understanding Riba (Interest) in Islam

• Definition: Riba literally means “increase” or “excess.” In Islamic finance, it refers to any unjustifiable increase in the principal amount of a loan or a transaction. It’s essentially charging money for money, or time for money, without a legitimate trade or risk-sharing.
• Quranic Prohibition: The Quran unequivocally condemns riba. For example, Surah Al-Baqarah (2:275) states, “Those who consume interest will stand [on Judgment Day] like one who has been struck by Satan into insanity… Allah has permitted trade and has forbidden interest.” Surah Al-Baqarah (2:279) warns, “And if you do not, then be informed of a war [against you] from Allah and His Messenger.” This clearly shows the severity of riba.
• Economic Rationale: Islamic scholars argue that riba leads to economic injustice, fosters exploitation of the needy, concentrates wealth, discourages real productivity and risk-taking, and promotes a debt-ridden society. It violates the principle of shared risk and reward essential for ethical commerce.

How “Buy Now Pay Later” Often Involves Riba

While BNPL services often advertise “0% interest,” a closer look reveals that they almost invariably have mechanisms that involve riba or violate other Islamic financial principles.

• Late Fees: The most common form of riba in BNPL schemes is the late fee. If a payment is missed, a penalty is charged, which is an increase on the principal amount due to delayed payment, fitting the definition of riba. Islamic finance allows for contractual penalties for non-performance but not an interest charge for late payments.
• Hidden Interest/Financing Charges: For larger purchases or longer repayment periods, BNPL services often transition to interest-bearing installment plans. Even if a specific initial period is interest-free, the overall contract allows for riba, making the entire transaction problematic.
• Discount for Early Payment (Opposite of Riba): If a BNPL service offers a discount for immediate cash payment versus an installment plan, that could be seen as riba in reverse or at least an incentive tied to payment delay, which is an issue.
• Contingent Contracts: The nature of the contract, where payment is deferred with penalties, can be seen as introducing gharar (excessive uncertainty) or maysir (gambling-like elements) if the penalties are disproportionate or unclear.

Specific BNPL Providers and Riba

• Klarna: While Klarna offers “Pay in 4” (four interest-free installments), it also offers “Pay in 30 days” and financing options that do charge interest. Their terms explicitly state potential interest rates for longer-term plans and late fees.
• ClearPay (Afterpay): ClearPay primarily focuses on the “Pay in 4” model, claiming no interest. However, they do charge significant late fees. For example, in the UK, late fees can be up to £24 per order. These late fees are considered riba in Islamic finance.

Impact on the Muslim Consumer

For a Muslim consumer, utilizing any of these BNPL services via Moramode.com for a purchase, especially one that is already ethically questionable (like human hair wigs), would mean knowingly engaging in a transaction that could involve riba. This is a direct violation of Islamic teachings and carries severe spiritual implications. Even if one intends to pay on time to avoid fees, the contract itself often allows for riba, which is the concern. The focus should be on seeking truly halal financial alternatives.