Greatbritishcoins.etsy.com Review

Based on looking at the website Greatbritishcoins.etsy.com, the shop appears to be a legitimate vendor of antique British coins, operating within the Etsy marketplace.

It specializes in historical coinage, offering a range of hammered and milled coins from various British historical periods.

Here’s an overall review summary:

• Platform: Etsy, a well-established e-commerce platform.
• Product Type: Genuine antique British hammered and milled coins, including gold and silver.
• Seller Location: Leeds, United Kingdom.
• Sales Volume: 446 sales reported.
• Customer Reviews: Consistently high, averaging 5 out of 5 stars from 134 reviews, with many mentioning fast delivery and good customer service.
• Response Time: Indicated as having “Speedy replies.”
• Online Presence: Links to Instagram and Facebook pages.
• Transparency: Shop policies regarding shipping, customs, payments, returns, and cancellations are clearly stated within the Etsy platform. Seller details name, email are provided.
• Ethical Consideration: Selling historical artifacts such as coins themselves is permissible as long as they are genuinely acquired and traded, which appears to be the case here. The nature of the items is historical and collectible, not related to forbidden categories.

The shop benefits significantly from being hosted on Etsy, which provides a layer of buyer protection and standardized practices.

The high volume of positive reviews and sales suggests a reliable operation.

The seller, Matthew, actively engages with customers, as indicated by “Speedy replies.” The detailed product categories and filtering options e.g., by price, period enhance the user experience for collectors.

The focus on historical items and numismatics presents a niche that appeals to enthusiasts and those seeking unique, tangible pieces of history.

Here are some alternatives for ethical and beneficial collecting and engagement with historical items:

• Historical Maps and Atlases: Collecting antique maps provides a fascinating glimpse into historical geography, cartography, and world exploration.
  • Key Features: Visual historical data, often unique artwork, can appreciate in value.
  • Average Price: Varies widely, from tens to thousands of dollars depending on rarity and condition.
  • Pros: Educational, aesthetically pleasing, tangible connection to history.
  • Cons: Can be fragile, requires careful storage, authentication may be needed for very rare pieces.
• Vintage Postage Stamps: Philately is a classic and educational hobby, offering insights into history, culture, and art through global postal systems.
  • Key Features: Diverse designs, historical significance, organized collecting.
  • Average Price: Very accessible, from a few dollars for common stamps to hundreds for rare ones.
  • Pros: Low barrier to entry, can be very educational, excellent for children.
  • Cons: Requires specialized storage albums, some rare stamps can be counterfeited.
• Antique Books and Manuscripts: Collecting old books connects you directly with historical texts, printing methods, and literary heritage.
  • Key Features: Original texts, historical bindings, often include illustrations.
  • Average Price: From under $100 for common old editions to thousands for first editions or rare manuscripts.
  • Pros: Rich historical and literary value, potential for significant appreciation, can be studied.
  • Cons: Requires climate-controlled storage, can be very expensive, condition is crucial.
• Historical Documents Non-Financial: This can include old letters, diplomas, property deeds, or government decrees, offering a direct link to past events and individuals.
  • Key Features: Primary source material, unique historical narratives, personal connection to the past.
  • Average Price: Varies widely based on historical significance and rarity.
  • Pros: Unique and personal historical artifacts, highly educational.
  • Cons: Can be fragile, requires specialized handling and preservation, authentication is paramount.
• Vintage Postcards: A highly accessible and visually rich collecting area, capturing historical scenes, architecture, and social life.
  • Key Features: Visual historical records, often depict vanished landmarks or events.
  • Average Price: Typically very affordable, from a few dollars to tens of dollars for rare ones.
  • Pros: Inexpensive, easy to store, wide variety of themes.
  • Cons: Condition can degrade easily, less significant monetary value than other collectibles.
• Antique Scientific Instruments: Collecting old scientific tools like compasses, telescopes, or microscopes combines historical interest with an appreciation for technological development.
  • Key Features: Intricate craftsmanship, functional historical objects, often beautiful display pieces.
  • Average Price: Can range from hundreds to thousands of dollars.
  • Pros: Educational regarding scientific history, often aesthetically valuable, can be functional.
  • Cons: Can be very expensive, requires specialized knowledge for proper care and authentication.
• Historical Military Memorabilia Non-Weaponry: Focus on items like uniforms, medals, flags, or historical documents related to military history, steering clear of weaponry to maintain ethical considerations.
  • Key Features: Tangible links to significant historical conflicts and personal stories.
  • Average Price: Varies immensely depending on rarity and historical importance.
  • Pros: Deep historical significance, can be part of extensive collections.
  • Cons: Can be controversial for some, authentication can be challenging, ethical considerations around some items.

Find detailed reviews on Trustpilot, Reddit, and BBB.org, for software products you can also check Producthunt.

IMPORTANT: We have not personally tested this company’s services. This review is based solely on information provided by the company on their website. For independent, verified user experiences, please refer to trusted sources such as Trustpilot, Reddit, and BBB.org.

Greatbritishcoins.etsy.com Review: A Deeper Dive into Numismatic Authenticity

When you’re into the world of antique coin collecting, especially online, the big question on everyone’s mind is authenticity. With Greatbritishcoins.etsy.com, being on the Etsy platform immediately lends a certain level of credibility, but a true requires looking beyond the surface. We’re talking about historical artifacts here, not mass-produced goods. The shop’s claim of “Genuine Antique British Hammered & Milled Coins” is a bold one, and our review aims to dissect how well they live up to it, based on the information provided on their storefront.

The Etsy Ecosystem: A Foundation for Trust?

Etsy, as a marketplace, has its own mechanisms for establishing trust. It’s not Amazon, nor is it eBay.

It’s carved out a niche for handcrafted and vintage items.

For Greatbritishcoins.etsy.com, operating within this ecosystem offers both benefits and limitations.

The platform provides a structured environment where sellers can display their wares, and buyers can leave public reviews.

• Seller Verification: While Etsy doesn’t perform deep authentication of every single item, it does require sellers to adhere to certain standards. The presence of a “Matthew” as the shop owner and a physical location in Leeds, UK, adds a layer of transparency.
• Review System Robustness: Etsy’s review system is critical. With 446 sales and an average rating of 5 out of 5 stars from 134 reviews, GreatBritishCoins presents a strong track record. These aren’t just numbers. they represent actual customer experiences. Phrases like “Good item. We are happy with item.” and “perfect. cute mini coin from my fav period of history. thank you, once again” from named and anonymized buyers suggest a generally positive reception.
• “Speedy Replies” Metric: Etsy highlights “Speedy replies,” indicating the seller’s responsiveness. In a world of online transactions, quick communication is often a hallmark of a reliable and professional vendor. This feature, if consistently maintained, contributes significantly to customer satisfaction and problem resolution.

Greatbritishcoins.etsy.com Products and Categorization

The shop’s inventory focuses exclusively on British historical coins, a specialization that often indicates expertise.

They offer clear categories, which is a good sign for collectors.

• Product Range:
  • Hammered Coins 41 items: These are some of the oldest, dating back to pre-milled periods, often irregular in shape due to the manufacturing process.
  • Early Milled Coins 38 items: Representing a transition period, showing early attempts at mechanized coin production.
  • Milled Coins 28 items: More modern in appearance, produced by machines, offering greater uniformity.
  • Victorian 1837 – 1901 48 items: A specific historical era, popular among collectors due to its distinct designs and historical context.
• Pricing Structure: The prices listed for coins, ranging from USD 85.12 for a “Queen Victoria Early Copper Halfpenny 1856” to USD 510.71 for a “Queen Victoria 1866 Silver Shilling Coin,” align with typical market values for genuine antique coins of varying rarity and condition. The presence of “FREE shipping” is also a notable perk.
• Item Descriptions: Each item lists the monarch, denomination, year, and material, along with tags like “Rare Coins,” “Genuine Coins,” and historical descriptors “Georgian,” “Victorian,” “Medieval”. This level of detail is crucial for collectors making informed decisions. The use of terms like “Genuine Antique” further reinforces the claim of authenticity.

Seller Credibility and Transparency

Beyond the products themselves, the “About GreatBritishCoins” section provides insights into the seller’s background and passion, which can build confidence.

• Seller Identity: Matthew, the owner, is based in Leeds, Yorkshire, UK. This geographical transparency is a positive indicator.
• Years in Business: “On Etsy since 2016” means they have over 8 years of experience operating on the platform, establishing a long-term presence.
• Mission Statement: The seller expresses a “passion for history and for numismatics,” emphasizing that “each coin is a unique piece of history.” This personal touch can resonate with buyers who share similar interests.
• Value Proposition: “Unlike most we try to bring you ‘affordable’ coins below the market value. We spend a lot of time sourcing coins at the best possible prices. This means we can pass on the savings to you, giving you the real benefit of our knowledge and expertise in the world of numismatics.” This suggests a commitment to competitive pricing and leveraging expertise for buyer benefit. However, determining “below market value” without direct comparison to professional grading services or auction results is difficult for an average buyer.

Customer Feedback and Engagement

The review section on Etsy is a goldmine of unfiltered feedback, offering a glimpse into real customer experiences. Mix-living.com Review

• Consistent 5-Star Ratings: The sheer volume of 5-star ratings across 134 reviews is impressive. This suggests a consistent level of quality and service.
• Specific Praises: Customers frequently commend the beauty and quality of the coins “Another beautiful coin,” “The coin is amazing and looked just like the image”, the fast delivery “Fast delivery too,” “They arrived promptly and was packaged very well”, and good customer service “Matthew is absolutely great to work with!”. These specific details are far more valuable than generic positive comments.
• Engagement: The seller’s “Speedy replies” metric and the positive comments about Matthew indicate active customer engagement, which is vital for resolving any potential issues and building trust.

Greatbritishcoins.etsy.com Cons

While Greatbritishcoins.etsy.com has many strong points, there are areas where a dedicated e-commerce site might offer more, or where the limitations of the Etsy platform become apparent.

• Lack of Independent Grading: While the seller states “Genuine Antique British Hammered & Milled Coins,” there’s no mention of third-party grading services e.g., PCGS, NGC which are standard in high-value numismatics for independent authentication and condition assessment. This is a common practice for serious collectors and a significant omission for high-value items, where grading can dramatically impact value and confidence.
• Limited High-Resolution Imagery: While Etsy allows for multiple photos, the standard resolution may not be sufficient for expert numismatists to assess specific features, die varieties, or subtle flaws crucial for accurate valuation. High-magnification images are often desired.
• No Dedicated Authentication Page/Process: Beyond the general Etsy policy, there’s no specific page or detailed explanation of their authentication process. For antique coins, especially those potentially worth hundreds of dollars, buyers might want to know how the seller verifies authenticity, rather than just taking their word for it.
• Return Policy Specificity: While Etsy has a general return policy, the shop states “See item details for return and exchange eligibility.” A clearer, universally applicable return policy on the main shop page might be beneficial, especially concerning authenticity claims.
• Sole Proprietor Operation: The “About” section suggests it’s primarily run by “Matthew.” While this can mean personalized service, it might also imply scalability limitations or potential delays if the owner is unavailable. The “Last updated on Dec 5, 2021” for the announcement and “Last updated on Jun 15, 2016” for shop policies might indicate less frequent updates on these specific sections compared to a dedicated, constantly maintained e-commerce site.
• Reliance on Etsy’s Security: While Etsy is generally secure for payments, the shop’s security is inherently tied to Etsy’s infrastructure. There are no independent security certificates or privacy policies directly from Greatbritishcoins.etsy.com itself, only references to Etsy’s policies.

Numismatic Industry Standards and Best Practices

In the broader numismatic world, certain standards are considered best practices for ensuring authenticity and value.

• Professional Grading Services: For high-value coins, submission to third-party grading services like the Professional Coin Grading Service PCGS or Numismatic Guaranty Corporation NGC is commonplace. These services encapsulate coins in tamper-evident holders and assign a standardized grade, significantly increasing buyer confidence and often value.
• Detailed Provenance: Serious collectors often seek coins with a clear “provenance,” meaning a documented history of ownership. While challenging for very old coins, any available historical records add immense value.
• High-Resolution Imaging: Professional coin dealers often provide extremely high-resolution, detailed images from multiple angles, sometimes with magnification, to allow buyers to inspect the coin’s surface, strike, and any imperfections.
• Expert Appraisals: Reputable dealers and auction houses employ or consult with numismatic experts who can provide detailed appraisals and authentication reports.

The absence of these elements within the Greatbritishcoins.etsy.com storefront suggests that while they are likely genuine and Matthew is a passionate dealer, buyers pursuing extremely high-value investments might seek more robust authentication methods found in established numismatic auction houses or dedicated professional dealers.

However, for the general collector looking for genuine, affordable historical pieces, the Etsy shop appears to be a solid choice based on its positive reviews and transparent operation.

Greatbritishcoins.etsy.com vs. Other Platforms

When considering where to purchase antique coins, Greatbritishcoins.etsy.com operates on Etsy, which has distinct characteristics compared to other popular platforms or specialized numismatic sites.

Understanding these differences can help buyers make informed decisions based on their needs and comfort levels.

Etsy vs. Dedicated Numismatic Marketplaces

Dedicated numismatic marketplaces, such as Stacks and Bowers Galleries or Heritage Auctions, are specifically designed for coin collectors and investors.

• Specialization and Expertise: Dedicated platforms typically have in-house numismatic experts who authenticate, grade, and catalog coins. They often provide extensive historical context and detailed condition reports, including professional grading PCGS, NGC.
• Auction vs. Direct Sale: Many specialized platforms operate on an auction model, which can lead to higher prices but also offers the thrill of bidding and the potential for rare finds. Etsy, and thus Greatbritishcoins.etsy.com, primarily uses a direct sale model with fixed prices.
• Authentication and Guarantees: These high-end platforms usually offer robust authenticity guarantees, sometimes backed by third-party insurance or certification. While Etsy offers buyer protection, it’s a general marketplace guarantee, not a numismatic-specific one.
• Target Audience: Dedicated numismatic sites cater to serious collectors and investors often seeking high-value, professionally graded pieces. Greatbritishcoins.etsy.com, being on Etsy, likely targets a broader audience, including casual collectors, gift-givers, and history enthusiasts.
• Fees and Pricing: Specialized auction houses often have buyer’s premiums and other fees, which can add significantly to the final price. Etsy sellers pay listing fees and transaction fees, which are typically absorbed into the item’s price.

Etsy vs. General Online Marketplaces e.g., eBay

EBay is a vast marketplace where anything from new items to rare collectibles is sold.

• Buyer Protection: Both Etsy and eBay offer buyer protection programs. Etsy’s system is generally seen as more curated towards handmade and vintage items, potentially fostering a closer community feel. eBay’s system is broad and covers a vast array of goods.
• Seller Vetting: On eBay, anyone can become a seller, and while feedback systems exist, the sheer volume can make it harder to distinguish truly reputable sellers from less reliable ones. Etsy, while open, feels a bit more community-driven, and shops like Greatbritishcoins.etsy.com benefit from Etsy’s focus on quality and seller transparency like the “Speedy replies” badge.
• Pricing Volatility: eBay’s auction format can lead to highly variable prices, while its fixed-price listings may still be subject to intense competition. Greatbritishcoins.etsy.com offers fixed prices, providing more predictability.
• Specialization vs. Breadth: Greatbritishcoins.etsy.com’s narrow focus on British coins on Etsy creates a specialized shop experience. On eBay, you’d have to filter through countless listings to find similar specialized offerings.

Etsy vs. Local Coin Dealers

Physical coin shops offer a tactile experience and direct interaction with experts.

• Tangibility: You can physically inspect coins before purchasing, which is invaluable for numismatics where condition is paramount. This is a significant advantage over any online platform.
• Expert Advice: Local dealers often have deep knowledge and can offer personalized advice, valuation, and authentication on the spot.
• Immediate Purchase: No shipping delays or costs.
• Convenience: Online shopping, like on Greatbritishcoins.etsy.com, offers unparalleled convenience and access to a wider inventory than most local shops. A local dealer’s inventory is limited by their physical space and sourcing.
• Pricing: Online prices can sometimes be more competitive due to lower overheads, as Matthew from Greatbritishcoins.etsy.com claims to source “below market value” to pass savings to buyers.

In summary, Greatbritishcoins.etsy.com on Etsy strikes a balance between the broad accessibility of general marketplaces and a more specialized focus. 2ndkitchen.com Review

It’s a good choice for those looking for genuine, affordably priced antique British coins with strong social proof, but it might not satisfy the most stringent requirements of high-end numismatists seeking professional grading and intricate provenance documentation.

How to Verify Authenticity for Antique Coins

Given that Greatbritishcoins.etsy.com sells antique coins, the question of authenticity is paramount.

While the shop has positive reviews, buyers should still understand the general methods for verifying antique coins, especially when making significant investments.

Key Verification Methods for Antique Coins

• Third-Party Grading and Authentication TPG: This is the gold standard for verifying authenticity and condition. Companies like PCGS Professional Coin Grading Service and NGC Numismatic Guaranty Corporation are independent services that:
  • Examine coins: Experts verify the coin’s authenticity against known counterfeits and for alterations.
  • Assign a grade: Coins are graded on a standardized scale e.g., Sheldon scale from 1 to 70 based on their condition, strike, and surface preservation.
  • Encapsulate: The coin is then sealed in a tamper-evident holder, along with a unique certification number.
  • Online Databases: These services maintain online databases where you can verify a coin’s certification number and images, ensuring it matches the graded coin.
• Expert Examination: If a coin is not slabbed by a TPG, a personal examination by a reputable numismatist or coin dealer is crucial. They can assess:
  • Weight and Dimensions: Comparing the coin’s actual weight and diameter against official specifications for its type and year. Variations can indicate counterfeits or alterations.
  • Metal Composition: While not always feasible for individual buyers, professional analysis can confirm the metal content.
  • Strike and Die Characteristics: Experts look for specific details in the strike, such as sharpness of features, die flaws, or evidence of tooling, which are unique to genuine issues.
  • Patina and Wear: Authentic antique coins will show natural wear and patina consistent with their age and circulation. Suspiciously “new” looking old coins or those with artificial toning can be red flags.
• Provenance and History: Understanding a coin’s “provenance” its documented history of ownership can add significant credibility. While challenging for very old coins, any available records from reputable auctions or established collections can increase confidence in its authenticity.
• Reputable Dealers and Marketplaces: Purchasing from well-established dealers, auction houses, or marketplaces with strong buyer protection policies is a primary line of defense. The long-standing positive reputation of Greatbritishcoins.etsy.com on Etsy is a good sign in this regard, but buyers should always be aware of the platform’s limitations compared to specialized numismatic authentication.
• Reference Materials: Numismatic books, catalogs, and online databases like the British Museum’s coin collection or reputable numismatic websites provide detailed information on specific coin types, their characteristics, known variants, and common counterfeits. Collectors can educate themselves to spot discrepancies.
• Magnification and Lighting: Using a loupe magnifying glass or microscope under good lighting allows for close inspection of details that might reveal tooling marks, casting seams, or other signs of counterfeiting not visible to the naked eye.

Applying to Greatbritishcoins.etsy.com Purchases

While Greatbritishcoins.etsy.com states their coins are “genuine,” it’s important for buyers to understand that they are likely purchasing raw coins i.e., not professionally graded and slabbed. This places the onus on the buyer to:

• Ask for more images: If possible, request additional high-resolution images or videos from the seller, especially of key details or edges.
• Research the specific coin: Before purchasing, research the specific coin type e.g., “1771 George III Copper Halfpenny” using external numismatic resources to understand its typical appearance, weight, and common counterfeits.
• Consider lower-value purchases first: For a first-time buyer from this shop, starting with a lower-priced item can be a way to test the waters and assess the seller’s claims and service before committing to a more expensive piece.
• Leverage Etsy’s Buyer Protection: If there are any doubts about authenticity upon receipt, Etsy’s buyer protection policies provide a mechanism for recourse.

Ultimately, while Greatbritishcoins.etsy.com has a strong positive reputation within the Etsy ecosystem, serious collectors investing significant sums might still choose to send newly acquired raw coins to a third-party grading service for independent authentication and grading, or consult with a local expert, to ensure maximum confidence.

Greatbritishcoins.etsy.com Pricing Strategy

The pricing strategy adopted by Greatbritishcoins.etsy.com, as described on their Etsy shop, is noteworthy for its explicit claim of offering “affordable’ coins below the market value.” This positions them as a value-driven option in the antique coin market.

Let’s break down how this strategy plays out and what it implies for buyers.

Claim of “Below Market Value”

The seller states: “Unlike most we try to bring you ‘affordable’ coins below the market value.

We spend a lot of time sourcing coins at the best possible prices.

This means we can pass on the savings to you, giving you the real benefit of our knowledge and expertise in the world of numismatics.” Spotlight-marketing.eu Review

• Sourcing Advantage: This suggests the owner, Matthew, has strong sourcing channels and numismatic knowledge that allows him to acquire coins at advantageous prices. This could involve direct purchases from private collections, estate sales, or less common auctions, rather than relying solely on mainstream numismatic channels where competition drives prices up.
• Value Proposition: For buyers, the promise of “below market value” is a significant draw. In a market where prices for genuine antiques can be steep, finding a seller focused on affordability can be appealing, especially for new collectors or those on a budget.
• Expertise as a Cost-Saving Mechanism: The phrasing implies that Matthew’s “knowledge and expertise” aren’t just for authentication, but also for identifying good deals and efficient sourcing, effectively translating into savings for the customer.

Range and Specific Examples

The prices visible on the homepage span a considerable range, from less than $100 USD for items like the “George III Farthing Copper Coin 1806” USD 99.30 to over $500 USD for pieces like the “Queen Victoria 1866 Silver Shilling Coin” USD 510.71.

• Varied Price Points: This wide range caters to different budget levels, making the shop accessible to both casual buyers seeking a historical keepsake and more serious collectors looking for mid-range items.
• Free Shipping: The inclusion of “FREE shipping” on all listed items is a significant value add, especially for international buyers. Shipping costs for valuable items, particularly cross-border, can be substantial, so this removes a common friction point and effectively lowers the overall cost to the buyer.

Implications for Buyers

• Buyer Research is Key: While the “below market value” claim is attractive, buyers should still perform their due diligence. “Market value” for antique coins is highly subjective and depends on numerous factors:
  • Condition Grade: Even slight differences in condition can mean significant price variations. Since coins on Greatbritishcoins.etsy.com are not independently graded, buyers rely on the seller’s assessment and their own visual inspection from photos.
  • Rarity: True rarity is a major determinant of value.
  • Historical Significance: Certain coins with unique historical stories can command premiums.
  • Demand: Popularity and current collecting trends also influence prices.
  • Source: Prices can vary between auction houses, specialized dealers, and general marketplaces.
• “Affordable” vs. “Bargain”: The terms “affordable” and “below market value” should be understood in the context of numismatics. An “affordable” antique coin might still be hundreds of dollars, but considered a good value compared to equivalent pieces in other venues. It doesn’t necessarily mean a “bargain” in the sense of being significantly undervalued.
• Trust in Seller’s Expertise: The pricing strategy heavily relies on the buyer’s trust in Matthew’s expertise in both sourcing and valuation. The positive reviews lend strong support to this trust, as customers consistently report satisfaction with their purchases.

In essence, Greatbritishcoins.etsy.com’s pricing strategy appears to be a conscious effort to offer competitive prices within the antique coin market, leveraging the owner’s sourcing skills.

For buyers, it represents an opportunity to acquire genuine historical coins without necessarily paying top-tier auction house premiums, but requires a foundational understanding of numismatic valuation or strong reliance on the shop’s established positive reputation.

Greatbritishcoins.etsy.com Customer Service and Reputation

A strong reputation and responsive customer service are paramount for any online business, especially when dealing with valuable items like antique coins.

Greatbritishcoins.etsy.com’s Etsy profile provides several indicators of its customer service quality and overall standing.

Speedy Replies: A Key Indicator

Etsy specifically highlights “Speedy replies” as a characteristic of Greatbritishcoins.etsy.com.

• Significance: This badge is awarded by Etsy based on the shop’s history of replying to messages quickly. In the online retail space, prompt communication is critical for:
  • Pre-purchase inquiries: Answering questions about specific coins, condition, or historical details.
  • Order status: Providing updates on shipping or delivery.
  • Problem resolution: Addressing any issues that may arise, such as shipping delays or concerns about an item.
• Impact on Buyer Confidence: Knowing that a seller is responsive builds confidence. It suggests that if a buyer has a question or an issue, they won’t be left waiting indefinitely, which is a common frustration in online shopping.
• Direct Contact: The option to “Contact shop owner Matthew” and “messaging them on Etsy” directly simplifies communication channels.

Rave Reviews: The Voice of the Customer

The shop boasts an “Average review rating is 4.8 or higher” and a perfect 5 out of 5 stars from 134 reviews. This is a powerful testament to their customer satisfaction.

• Volume and Consistency: With 446 sales, accumulating 134 reviews that maintain a perfect 5-star average is exceptional. It’s not just a few happy customers. it’s a significant portion of their clientele reporting positive experiences.
• Qualitative Feedback: Beyond the stars, the actual review comments offer valuable insights:
  • “Good item. We are happy with item.”
  • “perfect. cute mini coin from my fav period of history. thank you, once again”
  • “Another beautiful coin from Great British Coins!”
  • “Another super purchase from this seller. Highly recommend.”
  • “Wow this coin is amazing. As someone with a passion for ‘Stuart’ history i’ve found a new amazing site to shop. Fast delivery too. Thank you.”
  • “As always, Great British Coins is the place to shop for beautiful, quality coins, and great customer service. The coin is just as pictured- beautiful!”
  • “Matthew is absolutely great to work with!”
  • “Very nice and arrived soon”
  • “The coin is amazing and looked just like the image. It is obvious i will be back when the collections refill.”
  • “Just received the vintage coins. My son will love them. They arrived promptly and was packaged very well. Thank you!”
• Recurring Customers: Comments like “once again” and “Another super purchase” and “It is obvious i will be back” strongly suggest a base of loyal, repeat customers. This is a hallmark of a business that consistently delivers on its promises.
• Praise for Matthew: Specific mentions of “Matthew is absolutely great to work with!” and “good customer service” directly attribute the positive experience to the owner, indicating personalized and attentive service.
• Product Accuracy: Several reviews highlight that “The coin is just as pictured- beautiful!” and “looked just like the image,” which is crucial for online sales of unique items where visual representation is key.

Social Proof and Admirers

The shop also lists 596 Admirers, indicating the number of Etsy users who have favorited the shop.

• Beyond Purchase: These are users who haven’t necessarily bought something but appreciate the shop’s inventory or aesthetic, potentially marking it for future purchases or simply admiring its offerings. This further contributes to the shop’s overall positive social proof.

Shop Policies and Transparency

Greatbritishcoins.etsy.com provides clear shop policies on shipping, customs, payment options, returns, and cancellations.

• Clarity: Policies are stated in a straightforward manner, even if some details “See item details for return and exchange eligibility” require checking individual listings.
• Payment Security: Etsy handles all payment processing Paypal, Visa, Mastercard, Apple Pay, stating “Etsy keeps your payment information secure. Etsy shops never receive your credit card information,” which provides a significant layer of security for buyers.
• Cancellation Policy: “Cancellations: accepted Request a cancellation: before item has shipped” is a clear and reasonable policy.

In conclusion, Greatbritishcoins.etsy.com demonstrates a very strong reputation and excellent customer service based on its Etsy profile. Tamer.ai Review

The high volume of positive reviews, repeated customer satisfaction, and active communication all point towards a reliable and customer-focused operation.

FAQ

What is Greatbritishcoins.etsy.com?

Greatbritishcoins.etsy.com is an online shop on the Etsy marketplace specializing in the sale of genuine antique British hammered and milled coins from various historical periods, operated by Matthew from Leeds, United Kingdom.

Is Greatbritishcoins.etsy.com a legitimate seller?

Yes, based on its Etsy profile, Greatbritishcoins.etsy.com appears to be a legitimate seller with 446 sales and a consistent 5-star rating from 134 reviews, indicating high customer satisfaction and reliable operation.

What types of coins does Greatbritishcoins.etsy.com sell?

Greatbritishcoins.etsy.com sells a range of genuine antique British coins, including hammered coins, early milled coins, milled coins, and specific historical periods like Victorian-era coins 1837-1901.

How long has Greatbritishcoins.etsy.com been on Etsy?

The shop has been active on Etsy since 2016, indicating over eight years of experience operating on the platform.

What is the average customer review rating for Greatbritishcoins.etsy.com?

Greatbritishcoins.etsy.com has an average customer review rating of 5 out of 5 stars based on 134 reviews.

Does Greatbritishcoins.etsy.com offer free shipping?

Yes, many of the listed coins on Greatbritishcoins.etsy.com offer free shipping.

How quickly does Greatbritishcoins.etsy.com respond to messages?

Etsy highlights that Greatbritishcoins.etsy.com has a history of “Speedy replies,” meaning the seller responds to messages quickly.

What is the price range of coins on Greatbritishcoins.etsy.com?

Prices for coins on Greatbritishcoins.etsy.com vary, typically ranging from under USD 100 to over USD 500, depending on the coin’s rarity, material, and historical significance.

Are the coins on Greatbritishcoins.etsy.com professionally graded?

The information on the shop’s homepage does not indicate that the coins are professionally graded by third-party services like PCGS or NGC. they are sold as raw coins. Deotal.com Review

Can I trust the authenticity of coins from Greatbritishcoins.etsy.com?

The shop claims to sell “Genuine Antique British Hammered & Milled Coins,” and the strong positive reviews suggest customer satisfaction with authenticity.

However, for high-value purchases, independent verification is always recommended.

What payment methods does Greatbritishcoins.etsy.com accept?

As an Etsy shop, Greatbritishcoins.etsy.com accepts secure payment options processed through Etsy, including PayPal, Visa, Mastercard, and Apple Pay.

What is the return policy for Greatbritishcoins.etsy.com?

Greatbritishcoins.etsy.com’s return and exchange eligibility depend on the specific item details, but cancellations are accepted before an item has shipped.

Who is the owner of Greatbritishcoins.etsy.com?

The owner of Greatbritishcoins.etsy.com is Matthew, based in Leeds, West Yorkshire, United Kingdom.

Does Greatbritishcoins.etsy.com have social media presence?

Yes, Greatbritishcoins.etsy.com has links to an Instagram profile @GreatBritishCoins and a Facebook page from its Etsy shop.

Is purchasing antique coins from Greatbritishcoins.etsy.com ethical?

Yes, collecting historical artifacts such as coins is generally considered ethical, especially when the items are genuinely acquired and traded, which appears to be the case with Greatbritishcoins.etsy.com.

What if I have a problem with my order from Greatbritishcoins.etsy.com?

You can contact the shop owner, Matthew, directly through Etsy’s messaging system, and the “Speedy replies” badge suggests prompt assistance.

Etsy’s buyer protection policies also provide recourse.

Does Greatbritishcoins.etsy.com sell gold or silver coins?

Yes, the shop’s “About” section mentions that they buy and sell “gold & silver coins from Saxon through medieval, Tudor, Stuart, hammered & milled.” Rochakjaankari.com Review

How many items are currently listed on Greatbritishcoins.etsy.com?

The shop lists a total of 155 items across its various categories, with 41 Hammered Coins, 38 Early Milled Coins, 28 Milled Coins, and 48 Victorian coins.

What is the purpose of collecting antique coins?

Collecting antique coins is a hobby driven by historical interest, appreciation for craftsmanship, and the tangibility of holding a piece of the past.

It can also be an investment in appreciating assets.

Are there alternatives to collecting antique coins?

Yes, ethical and beneficial alternatives in similar niches include collecting Historical Maps and Atlases, Vintage Postage Stamps, Antique Books and Manuscripts, Historical Documents Non-Financial, Vintage Postcards, Antique Scientific Instruments, and Historical Military Memorabilia Non-Weaponry.