Let’s talk consignment. You’ve got a pile of clothes you’re not wearing, maybe some bags or shoes, and the dream is turning them into cash without the hassle of selling them yourself, right? That sounds great on paper, like found money. But just like anything else that promises a quick win, there are often fees involved that can seriously eat into your cut if you’re not paying attention. We’re not here to sugarcoat it. understanding exactly where your money goes is the absolute baseline for actually making money when you consign, and different platforms play this game by wildly different rules, as you’ll see.
| Feature | Poshmark | Tradesy | ThredUp | The RealReal | eBay | Facebook Marketplace | Vestiaire Collective |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Primary Fee Structure | Fixed Percentage e.g., 20% of final sale | Variable Percentage depends on item price | Variable Payout based on ThredUp assessment and sale price | Variable Percentage higher, depends on brand, category, item | Listing Fee + Final Value Fee percentage of sale | None Explicit | Complex Percentage + Commission + Handling Fees |
| Typical Fee Range | Moderate | Moderate to High | Low to Moderate Payout % often feels high vs. potential sale value | High | Varies Moderate overall depending on category/format | Effectively Zero direct cash | High |
| Effort Level for Seller | Moderate Listing, Photo, Shipping, Customer Service | Moderate Listing, Photo, Shipping, Customer Service – options exist | Very Low Send in bag | Low Send in items, they handle everything | High Listing, Photo, Shipping, Customer Service, Marketing | Very High Listing, Photo, Negotiation, Meeting Buyers, Risk Management | Low Send in items, they handle processing |
| Authentication Process | Seller’s responsibility primarily | Some options/programs available | Basic quality check only | Rigorous Expert Authentication | Primarily Seller’s responsibility some programs exist | None – Seller/Buyer manage | Rigorous Expert Authentication |
| Hidden/Additional Fees | Shipping buyer pays, but impacts attractiveness, promoting req’d for reach | Shipping paid by buyer, optional premium services | Fees for unaccepted items return fee, low payout feels like a ‘fee’ | High Shipping & Insurance costs, potential processing fees | Listing fees, Promotion fees, Store fees, Dispute fees | Time, Effort, Risk of scams/disputes, Lack of marketing support | Handling fees, Potential return shipping if item is rejected/unsold |
| Control Over Pricing | High Seller sets price, can offer discounts/bundles | High Seller sets price, can offer discounts | None ThredUp sets price and pays based on their system | Limited The RealReal suggests/sets price based on market & their assessment | High Seller sets price, auction or fixed | Very High Seller sets price, negotiates directly | Limited Vestiaire Collective sets price, potential for price reviews |
| Target Audience | General Fashion & Home Goods large, broad | Women’s Fashion slightly more upscale focus than Poshmark | Mass Market, Fast Fashion, Convenience-focused | Luxury Goods Only designer clothing, bags, jewelry | Everything massive, very broad | Local, General Items broad, community-driven | High-End Luxury Fashion |
| Link | Poshmark | Tradesy | ThredUp | The RealReal | eBay | Facebook Marketplace | Vestiaire Collective |
Read more about Where to Buy Consignment Fee
Understanding Consignment Fees: What You’re Actually Paying For
Look, let’s be honest. Consignment isn’t magic.
You’re not just handing over your clothes and watching money magically appear.
There’s a cost involved, and understanding that cost is the first step to maximizing your profits. This isn’t some theoretical exercise. we’re talking real money.
We’ll break down exactly what you’re paying for when you consign your items, and, more importantly, how to minimize those fees and maximize your returns.
Think of this as your pre-consignment cheat sheet—because knowing the game is half the battle.
Decoding the Fee Structure: Percentage vs. Flat Rate.
First things first: consignment platforms typically use one of two fee structures: percentage-based or flat-rate. A percentage-based fee takes a cut of your final sale price, often ranging from 20% to 40% or even higher depending on the platform. Platforms like Poshmark and Tradesy often operate on this model. Conversely, a flat-rate fee charges a fixed amount per item, regardless of the selling price. This can be attractive for lower-priced items, but for high-value pieces, a percentage-based fee might be more palatable.
Let’s look at some examples.
Imagine you sell a dress for $100. On Poshmark, with a 20% fee, you’d keep $80. On a platform with a $5 flat fee, you’d keep $95. But if that dress sold for $500, the picture changes dramatically.
A 20% fee on Poshmark leaves you with $400, while the $5 flat fee would leave you with $495. See? Context matters.
Here’s a quick comparison table:
| Platform | Fee Structure | Example $100 Item | Example $500 Item |
|---|---|---|---|
| Poshmark | 20% | $80 | $400 |
| Tradesy | Percentage Variable | Varies | Varies |
| Hypothetical | $5 Flat Rate | $95 | $495 |
| ThredUp | Variable Percentage | Varies | Varies |
The key here is to understand each platform’s specific structure before you start listing. Don’t be caught off guard by hidden fees! This isn’t rocket science, but it does require a bit of homework. ThredUp offers a completely different approach which we will examine later.
Hidden Costs: Photography, Processing, and Other Fees.
Beyond the upfront consignment fee, there are often secondary charges to consider.
Some platforms might charge extra for professional photography, which can significantly impact your bottom line.
Similarly, there can be processing fees, which cover the costs of handling, cleaning, and storing your items. And let’s not forget shipping costs.
These can eat into your profits if you don’t plan carefully.
The RealReal, for example, often has higher shipping fees due to their focus on luxury goods and more stringent shipping requirements to ensure the high-value items arrive safely.
- Photography Fees: These can range from a few dollars per item to a percentage of the sale price.
- Processing Fees: Expect fees for cleaning, inspecting, and storing your items.
- Shipping Fees: Consider both outgoing and return shipping costs—if the item doesn’t sell.
This is the stuff they often don’t tell you upfront—the fine print that can sting. Always, always, always read the terms and conditions before you commit. It’s tedious, I know, but it’s the difference between a successful consignment experience and one that leaves you feeling ripped off. These hidden costs can add up, especially when you’re dealing with multiple items.
Negotiating Fees: Tips and Tricks for Better Deals.
Believe it or not, negotiating consignment fees isn’t always a pipe dream.
While some platforms are more rigid than others, there are still avenues to explore.
For example, consider the volume of items you’re consigning.
If you’re sending a large batch, you might be able to negotiate a bulk discount.
Or, explore the possibility of offering a higher commission to the platform in exchange for expedited processing or premium marketing features.
- Bulk Discounts: Negotiate lower fees when consigning many items simultaneously.
- Higher Commission for Premium Services: Trade a higher commission for better marketing or faster processing.
- Compare Platforms: Leverage competing offers to your advantage.
Remember, it’s all about the power of leverage.
Do your research, know your worth, and don’t be afraid to ask. The worst they can say is no.
But remember that eBay and Facebook Marketplace often provide a different dynamic, with the fees and negotiations shifting based on your individual approach.
ThredUp Consignment Fee Breakdown: Is it Worth It?
ThredUp operates on a unique model compared to other platforms.
Instead of a straightforward commission, ThredUp uses a Clean Out Kit, where you ship them a bag of clothes, and they assess what they’ll accept.
You get a payout based on what they keep and sell, but you don’t get to set prices or control the sales process.
It’s a bit of a gamble, but for those looking for a simple solution with minimal effort, it could be appealing.
The lack of control, however, is a major tradeoff to consider.
ThredUp’s Fee Structure: A Detailed Look.
ThredUp doesn’t exactly publicize a flat fee structure.
Instead, your return depends heavily on the items ThredUp deems sellable and the ultimate sale price. Think of it as a “what they will give you” deal.
It’s not necessarily a consignment fee in the traditional sense, more of a “we’ll take what we can use and give you a cut” agreement.
You send them items, they assess, and you get a payout.
What’s more, the items they don’t accept are either donated or recycled, completely out of your control.
- Clean Out Kit: Order a kit, fill it with clothes, and ship it to ThredUp.
- Assessment and Selection: ThredUp evaluates your items, keeping only those that meet their criteria.
- Payout: You receive a payout based on the sale price of accepted items, minus ThredUp’s fees. The percentage taken varies depending on the item and its sale price.
- Unsold Items: Items not accepted are typically donated or recycled.
It’s crucial to understand the inherent uncertainty here.
You lack price control, making it tricky to predict your final payout.
While it’s extremely convenient, you relinquish considerable control over the process.
Profitability Analysis: Maximizing Returns on ThredUp.
To maximize your return on ThredUp, focus on sending high-quality, in-demand items. Research current trends.
Understanding the market makes a massive difference.
Clean, high-quality clothing in popular brands and sizes is more likely to be accepted and generate higher payouts.
Avoid sending heavily worn, damaged, or outdated clothing.
ThredUp’s acceptance criteria can be somewhat subjective, so focus on items that clearly meet their quality standards.
- Brand Awareness: Prioritize well-known brands with consistent resale value.
- Item Condition: Focus on items in excellent condition—no stains, rips, or significant wear.
- Current Trends: Stay updated on the hottest fashion styles and ship what’s likely to sell fast.
Consider it a calculated gamble. You’re trading convenience for control.
If time is of the essence, this may be your best bet.
But if you want fine-grained control over your pricing and sales process, other platforms may be more suitable.
Unlike Poshmark, Tradesy, or The RealReal, ThredUp’s simplicity comes at the cost of lower potential profits and control.
ThredUp’s Acceptance Rate: What to Expect.
ThredUp’s acceptance rate isn’t publicly available, and it’s notoriously inconsistent.
What gets accepted one time might be rejected the next, making it tricky to get a precise handle on profitability.
This lack of transparency adds to the inherent risk of using ThredUp for consignment.
The unpredictability means that while it might be a convenient option for offloading a large amount of clothing quickly, it’s not the most reliable way to consistently generate income from consignment.
Consider these factors:
- Seasonality: Seasonal items may have better or worse acceptance rates depending on the time of year.
- Brand Recognition: Popular, well-known brands are often preferred.
- Item Condition: The higher the quality of the clothes, the greater the chance of acceptance.
This makes planning challenging.
You may end up with a low payout despite spending time cleaning, sorting, and shipping your clothes.
Again, it’s a trade-off: convenience versus control and predictability.
If you’re aiming for a reliable income stream, explore other options like eBay or Poshmark which offer greater transparency and control, even if they require more hands-on work.
The RealReal Consignment: Luxury Goods, Luxury Fees?
The RealReal occupies a unique niche in the consignment world.
They specialize in luxury goods, which means higher prices, but also higher fees.
They’re known for their rigorous authentication process, adding a layer of confidence for buyers and therefore justifying their premium pricing and fees. But does this added expertise justify the costs? Let’s dive in.
The RealReal’s Fee Structure Compared to Competitors.
The RealReal’s fee structure is significantly different than platforms like Poshmark or ThredUp. They charge a percentage of the final sale price, but the percentage can vary depending on the brand, category, and item condition, frequently leaning towards the higher end of the spectrum compared to other platforms.
While Poshmark might take 20%, The RealReal could easily take 30% or more.
This disparity is partly due to their authentication process, which involves specialized experts verifying the authenticity of each item.
This process adds overhead cost to their operation, and a larger cut reflects that operational reality.
However, consider this: The RealReal’s rigorous authentication process builds trust, attracting higher-end buyers who are willing to pay more for the assurance of authenticity.
This premium positioning is reflected in their fees.
This strategy is vastly different from something like eBay, where authenticity verification is primarily the responsibility of the buyer and seller.
The RealReal’s Expertise: Does it Justify the Higher Fees?
The key differentiator with The RealReal is their expertise in luxury goods.
They invest heavily in authentication and provide a platform for buyers who specifically seek guaranteed authenticity.
This expertise comes at a cost, which is reflected in the higher fees.
But for high-value items, the added security and reassurance of authenticity offered by The RealReal can justify the higher commission. This is where that trust factor comes into play.
Consider this: Would you be comfortable selling a $5,000 handbag on Facebook Marketplace? Probably not.
The RealReal provides that added level of confidence and security that makes selling high-value items less risky.
While the fees are higher, the potential payoff for high-value items can make it worthwhile.
It’s a calculated gamble, but one potentially worth taking for luxury items.
Shipping and Insurance Costs with The RealReal.
Shipping luxury items requires extra care and attention, resulting in higher shipping costs.
The RealReal often incorporates insurance into their shipping process, ensuring your items are adequately protected against loss or damage during transit.
This adds to the overall expense, but it also offers significant peace of mind, especially for sellers dealing with high-value consignments.
It’s a premium service for a premium cost, which is what you pay for when dealing with luxury goods.
It’s a different game than simply listing a shirt on Poshmark.
Think of it this way: insurance is an investment in peace of mind, ensuring that your valuable items reach their destination safely.
While it adds to the cost, the security it provides can be worth the premium, particularly when dealing with high-value items.
Poshmark Consignment: A Seller’s Perspective
Poshmark is one of the largest and most popular consignment platforms out there.
It offers a user-friendly interface and a massive built-in audience.
But what about the fees? Let’s break down the Poshmark consignment experience.
Poshmark Fees: Understanding the Percentage Based Model.
Poshmark operates on a straightforward percentage-based fee structure.
They take a cut of your sale price, a percentage which is fixed across the board, meaning it doesn’t change based on the price of the item.
This makes it easy to calculate your potential profits upfront.
This predictability is a definite advantage over platforms with fluctuating fees or hidden costs, unlike the somewhat opaque nature of ThredUp. However, remember that their percentage can still be significant, so don’t forget to account for this when setting your prices.
Here’s a breakdown:
- Selling Fee: Poshmark takes a percentage of each sale.
- Shipping Fee: The buyer pays shipping, but sellers handle the actual shipping process.
- No Listing Fees: Poshmark doesn’t charge to list your items, making it attractive for those selling in volume.
Poshmark’s ease of use and wide reach makes it a great option, but the seller still carries the responsibility of handling the shipping and customer service aspects of the sales process.
It’s a different approach compared to The RealReal’s premium, hands-off approach.
Poshmark’s Marketing Reach: Weighing the Pros and Cons.
Poshmark’s significant advantage lies in its large user base. This provides unparalleled reach for your listings.
However, the sheer volume of items listed on the platform also means fierce competition.
To stand out, you need high-quality photos, competitive pricing, and effective marketing strategies.
You’re competing against thousands, if not millions of other sellers, a vastly different market than, say, Facebook Marketplace’s more localized approach.
- Large User Base: Access to a wide range of potential buyers.
- Social Aspect: Poshmark encourages a social aspect, which can be helpful for building a following.
Strategies to Increase Sales on Poshmark.
To boost your sales on Poshmark, leverage several key strategies: high-quality photos are essential to capture attention and showcase your items effectively.
Competitive pricing will also ensure you stay in the game. Actively participate in the community.
engaging with other users and building a reputation will help increase your visibility and establish trust with potential buyers. Regularly update your closet.
keeping it fresh and relevant ensures consistent visibility in the platform’s search results.
Offering bundles and discounts can sweeten deals and boost sales.
The competitive nature of the platform means you cannot afford to be passive.
Tradesy Consignment: Finding Your Niche
Tradesy focuses on women’s fashion, making it a niche platform compared to the broader appeal of Poshmark or eBay. This specialized focus can be an advantage for sellers with items that fit within Tradesy’s target audience.
Tradesy’s Fee Structure and its Advantages.
Tradesy also uses a percentage-based fee structure, similar to Poshmark. Their fees can vary, but are generally competitive with other major players in the consignment market. The key advantage here is their targeted audience.
If you’re selling women’s designer fashion, Tradesy could be a better option than other broader platforms.
This concentration reduces competition in your niche, improving your odds of success.
It’s a contrasting strategy to the broader appeal of eBay which caters to a far wider range of goods and buyers.
Tradesy’s Target Audience and How to Reach Them.
Tradesy’s target audience consists primarily of women looking for designer or upscale clothing.
Understanding this demographic is critical for success.
High-quality product photos and detailed descriptions are essential to attract this discerning clientele.
Focus on selling items that align with this audience’s preferences and fashion sensibilities.
This targeted focus differentiates it from platforms like Facebook Marketplace that cater to a far broader range of shoppers.
Tradesy vs. Poshmark: A Direct Comparison of Fees and Services No Comparison.
Note: As requested, no comparison between Tradesy and Poshmark is provided here. However, each platform has its unique strengths and weaknesses.
The key takeaway is to thoroughly investigate each platform’s specific fee structure and target audience to determine which one best aligns with your selling goals and the types of items you’re hoping to consign.
This nuanced approach will optimize your chances of success. Remember, research is key.
Selling on eBay: Consignment Fee Considerations
eBay is a behemoth in the online marketplace world.
While not exclusively a consignment platform, it’s a powerful tool for selling used goods, including consigned items.
The key here is understanding eBay’s fee structure, which is different than dedicated consignment sites.
eBay’s Listing Fees vs. Selling Fees.
eBay’s fee structure is multifaceted.
They charge listing fees for creating listings and selling fees a percentage of the final sale price when an item sells.
The specifics vary based on the item category and listing format.
Therefore, carefully analyze these fees before listing your items to ensure profitable sales.
Unlike many consignment platforms, eBay’s fees are directly related to the specific actions taken listing and selling rather than a simple percentage of the final sale.
This increased transparency requires more upfront calculation, yet also offers greater control.
Optimizing Your eBay Listings for Maximum Profit.
To maximize profits on eBay, optimize your listings.
High-quality photos, detailed descriptions, competitive pricing, and excellent customer service are essential.
Leverage eBay’s search features to effectively categorize and tag your listings.
This ensures your items appear prominently in relevant searches, driving organic traffic to your listings.
Furthermore, consider utilizing eBay’s various promotion tools to further enhance your listing’s visibility.
It’s a different level of hands-on work compared to the more passive approach of using ThredUp, yet it could offer greater potential returns.
eBay’s Buyer Protection: Impact on Seller Fees.
EBay’s buyer protection program provides a degree of security for buyers, which impacts sellers.
While this buyer protection is generally a positive aspect it promotes trust and encourages sales, it also means that sellers need to be meticulous in ensuring accurate product descriptions and prompt shipping.
Poor performance could lead to negative feedback and potential disputes which could lead to further fees or suspensions.
This is a double-edged sword, but managing expectations and providing a quality experience will protect you from penalties and maintain your seller reputation.
Facebook Marketplace: Consignment—Free or Fee-Heavy?
Facebook Marketplace might seem like a free consignment option, but there are hidden costs to consider.
While it doesn’t charge listing fees, the lack of built-in buyer protection and marketing features means more work for you, adding indirect costs.
The “Free” Consignment of Facebook Marketplace: Hidden Costs.
Facebook Marketplace doesn’t charge explicit listing fees, making it seem like a no-brainer. However, there are implicit costs.
The absence of buyer protection puts the responsibility of handling disputes squarely on the seller’s shoulders, resulting in potential time and hassle costs.
Additionally, the platform’s marketing features are rudimentary at best, meaning you need to put in extra effort to reach potential buyers yourself.
This effort in time and energy represents a hidden cost that needs to be factored in when assessing the overall cost-benefit of using Facebook Marketplace.
Reaching Buyers on Facebook Marketplace Effectively.
To reach buyers effectively on Facebook Marketplace, create compelling listings with high-quality photos and detailed descriptions.
Use relevant keywords in your descriptions to improve search visibility.
Interact with potential buyers promptly and professionally to build trust and encourage purchases.
Leverage your personal Facebook network to promote your listings—it’s a much more personal approach than other platforms.
Also, focus on local sales to minimize shipping costs and potential problems.
Risks and Rewards of Selling on Facebook Marketplace.
Facebook Marketplace presents a high-risk, high-reward scenario.
The low barriers to entry can attract many buyers, but also many less reputable buyers and sellers.
The absence of built-in buyer protection and the reliance on local transactions mean you are more exposed to scams or disputes.
On the plus side, it’s easy to use and can attract local customers.
It requires a greater level of caution compared to the more structured environment of other platforms.
The overall cost-benefit calculation requires a detailed assessment of your willingness to take on increased risks for a potentially lower profit margin.
Weigh this carefully, considering the lack of buyer protection compared to eBay’s system.
Vestiaire Collective: High-End Consignment, High-End Fees?
Vestiaire Collective is another platform focusing on luxury goods, similar to The RealReal.
However, they have a distinct approach, catering to a specific demographic of high-end consumers.
Vestiaire Collective’s Fee Structure: A Deep Dive.
Vestiaire Collective’s fee structure is complex, incorporating percentages, varying based on the item’s brand, condition, and sale price.
They also charge commission fees and often additional handling fees, depending on the specifics of each item.
The complexity requires careful evaluation before consignment to determine the ultimate profitability.
Again, it’s a different game than the simpler percentage models of Poshmark and Tradesy. It is also quite a different calculation from using ThredUp where your fee is far more unpredictable.
Authenticity Verification: The Value Proposition of Vestiaire Collective.
Similar to The RealReal, Vestiaire Collective prides itself on rigorous authenticity verification.
This assurance of authenticity adds considerable value for buyers, justifying the higher fees.
This trust-building mechanism is a fundamental aspect of their business model and is central to their high-end positioning.
Consider the peace of mind this added level of authentication provides.
This makes it worth considering for high-value items, especially when selling to discerning buyers who demand assurance.
This is quite different from using something like Facebook Marketplace, where you shoulder the burden of authenticity verification.
Marketing and Reach: Does Vestiaire Collective Deliver?
Vestiaire Collective targets a sophisticated customer base, focusing on a niche market for luxury fashion.
Their marketing strategy aligns with this, aiming to attract discerning buyers who appreciate their high-end offerings and rigorous authentication process.
While their reach isn’t as broad as Poshmark, their concentration on a niche market potentially provides better sales conversions for items that fit their target demographic.
The targeted approach is a double-edged sword, requiring that you focus on items that clearly align with their specific customer profile.
Frequently Asked Questions
What exactly is a consignment fee, and why do I have to pay it?
let’s strip this down. A consignment fee isn’t just some arbitrary charge.
It’s the cost of doing business with a platform or store that’s selling your items for you.
Think of it as paying for their service – their expertise, their marketing, their customer base, and often, their handling of the entire sales process from listing to shipping.
You pay it because they’re providing the platform and doing the heavy lifting of finding a buyer, processing the transaction, and often dealing with shipping and returns.
Platforms like Poshmark, Tradesy, The RealReal, and even places like eBay in a different structure, charge fees because they’ve built the marketplace and the infrastructure that allows you to turn your unwanted stuff into cash without starting from zero yourself.
It’s the price of leveraging their established ecosystem and customer trust.
Without that fee, they couldn’t operate, market your items, or facilitate the sales that get you paid.
What’s the main difference between percentage-based and flat-rate consignment fees?
This is fundamental, so let’s get this straight. Percentage-based fees, which are common on platforms like Poshmark and Tradesy, mean the platform takes a percentage of the final sale price of your item. So, if your item sells for $100 and the fee is 20%, you pay $20 and keep $80. If it sells for $500, you pay $100 and keep $400 at that same 20% rate. The fee scales with the price. Flat-rate fees, on the other hand, charge a fixed amount per item, regardless of its selling price. For example, a platform might charge a $5 flat fee. If your item sells for $100, you keep $95. If it sells for $500, you keep $495. See how the math changes depending on the item’s value? A flat fee can be great for lower-value items but bites hard into the profit of high-value ones. Conversely, a percentage fee might feel high on a luxury piece but leave you more on lower-priced goods. Knowing which model a platform uses is critical for calculating your actual potential earnings before you list.
Can you give me a practical example comparing percentage vs. flat fees?
Absolutely, let’s hammer this home with numbers, because that’s where the rubber meets the road. Imagine you have an item you list for $100. On a platform like Poshmark with a typical 20% fee for sales over $15 it’s a bit different for smaller sales, but sticking to the core idea, you’d pay $20 in fees and pocket $80. Now, take that same $100 item to a hypothetical platform with a $5 flat fee per item. You’d only pay $5 and keep $95. Pretty straightforward, right? But flip the script: what if your item is a high-value designer piece selling for $500? On that 20% percentage-based platform like Tradesy where percentages can vary, a 20% cut means a $100 fee, leaving you with $400. On the $5 flat-fee platform, you still only pay $5 and keep $495. This example makes it crystal clear: the value of the item you’re selling dictates which fee structure is more advantageous for your wallet. You need to run the numbers for your specific items on each platform you’re considering.
What are some common “hidden costs” I might encounter with consignment platforms?
Ah, the fine print – the stuff that can sneak up and eat your profits if you’re not paying attention. Beyond the primary consignment fee percentage or flat, platforms often layer on other charges. A big one is photography fees. Some higher-end or full-service platforms might offer professional photos, but this isn’t free. it can be a per-item charge or a percentage add-on. Then there are processing fees, which cover the platform’s costs for receiving, inspecting, cleaning, and perhaps storing your items before they’re listed. Don’t forget shipping fees. While on platforms like Poshmark, the buyer pays a fixed rate, other platforms might handle shipping differently, and if an item doesn’t sell and you want it back, you might be on the hook for return shipping. The RealReal, dealing with luxury goods, often has more robust and costly shipping protocols that factor into the overall cost. These aren’t always advertised as prominently as the main consignment fee, so you must read the terms or look for fee breakdowns before you send anything in. Ignoring these can turn a potentially profitable sale into a break-even, or worse, a loss.
Is it actually possible to negotiate consignment fees with platforms?
Look, the big online platforms like Poshmark, ThredUp, or The RealReal generally have fixed, non-negotiable fee structures because they’re dealing with massive volume and standardized processes. It’s not like haggling at a local antique shop. However, this doesn’t mean negotiation is completely off the table everywhere or in every circumstance. If you’re dealing with a local brick-and-mortar consignment store, yes, there’s often room to negotiate, especially if you’re bringing in high-value items or a large volume. With online platforms, your leverage is usually limited to your volume of items. Sending in a massive collection might open the door to a conversation about a bulk discount on processing or slightly adjusted percentages, though this is more likely for power sellers or specific promotions. You could also explore if offering a slightly higher commission yes, giving them more money could get you premium placement or faster processing, if that’s valuable to you. Platforms like eBay and Facebook Marketplace are different. negotiation there is usually item-by-item with the buyer, not about the platform’s core fees themselves, which are mostly non-negotiable but vary by listing type eBay or are non-existent Facebook, aside from optional paid features. The bottom line: don’t expect to chat down the percentage on Poshmark, but always check the terms for volume incentives or reach out if you have a truly exceptional haul for a platform like The RealReal.
How does ThredUp’s approach to consignment fees differ from traditional models?
ThredUp is a beast of a different color in the consignment jungle. They don’t operate on a standard “you set the price, we take a cut” model like Poshmark or Tradesy. Instead, you send them a “Clean Out Kit” filled with your clothes. They decide what they’ll accept, they set the price, and they give you a payout based on that price, minus their cut. This payout structure is variable, heavily dependent on the brand, item category, and what price they ultimately get for it. You don’t have control over the pricing or the sales process. It’s less a consignment fee in the traditional sense and more like selling your clothes to them at a price they determine after assessment, with your payout being a percentage of their eventual sale price. What they don’t accept is typically donated or recycled, again, out of your control. This model prioritizes convenience above all else, trading control and potentially higher profits for speed and simplicity. It’s a far cry from the hands-on listing you do on eBay or Facebook Marketplace.
What’s involved in the ThredUp Clean Out Kit process?
The ThredUp Clean Out Kit is the entry point for their system. First, you order a kit from their website.
They send you a bag, and you fill it with the clothes you want to get rid of.
You can choose to have items returned if they’re not accepted for a fee or have them donated/recycled automatically.
You then ship the bag back to ThredUp using the provided label.
Once they receive it, their team goes through your items, assesses their quality, brand, and condition, and decides which ones they will list on their site.
This assessment process determines your payout – or if you get anything at all for certain items. It’s a batch process.
You send a whole bag, and they process it all together.
This convenience is why people use it, but remember, you’re giving up control over which items are deemed sellable and what price they’ll fetch.
It’s designed to be easy, not necessarily the most profitable route compared to actively selling on platforms like Poshmark or The RealReal.
How is the payout calculated on ThredUp, and why is it so variable?
The payout on ThredUp is where things get a bit opaque, which contributes to its variability. They don’t have a simple fixed percentage like Poshmark. Your payout is a percentage of the sale price ThredUp sets, but that percentage varies significantly based on the item’s category, brand, and the ultimate sale price. For lower-value items, your percentage might be quite small, sometimes just 5-15%. For higher-end designer items, the percentage might increase, potentially up to 60-80% for very high-priced luxury goods. The variability comes from their internal pricing algorithm and category segmentation. They are essentially buying your item from you for a portion of what they think they can sell it for, and that portion changes based on their perceived risk, the item’s demand, and its value. You don’t get to see the breakdown beforehand, which makes predicting your earnings difficult. This is a major difference compared to platforms like Tradesy or Vestiaire Collective, where fee structures, while sometimes complex, are generally published or calculable upfront.
What kinds of items should I send to ThredUp to maximize my payout?
To maximize your chances of a decent payout from ThredUp, you need to be strategic about what goes into that Clean Out Kit. Forget sending anything worn, damaged, or outdated. they have strict quality standards, and those items will likely just get recycled or donated with no payout. Focus on items in excellent, like-new condition. Prioritize popular, current brands that are in demand. ThredUp is looking for items they know they can sell quickly. Researching brands they typically carry and focusing on classic, in-season styles will increase the likelihood of your items being accepted and getting a better payout percentage. Avoid off-brand or heavily worn pieces. Think of it less as sending them your entire closet clean-out and more as curating a selection of high-potential items. This strategy is crucial because unlike selling yourself on eBay or Facebook Marketplace where you control the listing and photos, with ThredUp you’re relying entirely on their assessment and sales process.
What happens to items ThredUp doesn’t accept from my Clean Out Kit?
This is an important detail often overlooked with the ThredUp model. When you send in a Clean Out Kit, ThredUp goes through everything and decides what meets their criteria for resale. Items that don’t make the cut are handled based on your selection when you ordered the kit. You can choose to have them returned to you, but this usually involves paying a return shipping and processing fee, which can sometimes be quite high and potentially negate any payout you got from the accepted items. Alternatively, and more commonly, you can opt to have the unaccepted items automatically donated or recycled by ThredUp. This means once they’re gone, they’re gone – you won’t get them back, and you won’t get paid for them. This lack of control over unsold or unaccepted items is a significant trade-off for the convenience ThredUp offers compared to platforms where you retain possession until an item sells, like Poshmark or eBay.
What kind of acceptance rate should I expect from ThredUp? Is it predictable?
ThredUp‘s acceptance rate is notoriously unpredictable and not publicly disclosed.
There are countless anecdotes from users describing wildly different outcomes from one kit to the next, even with similar items.
This variability is one of the biggest frustrations for sellers using ThredUp. Factors that influence acceptance include the current inventory levels ThredUp already has, the time of year seasonality matters, the specific assessor reviewing your bag, the perceived demand for the brand and style at that moment, and of course, the item’s condition.
Because it’s a black box process, you can’t rely on getting a consistent percentage of your items accepted each time.
This makes it very hard to use ThredUp as a predictable income stream.
If predictability is what you’re after, platforms where you control the listing process and see exactly what items are active, like Poshmark, Tradesy, or even eBay, are generally better options, despite requiring more effort on your part.
Why are The RealReal’s consignment fees generally higher than platforms like Poshmark or ThredUp?
The RealReal operates in a different league – the luxury market.
Their higher fees reflect the premium service they provide, centered around rigorous authentication.
When you consign with The RealReal, they have a team of experts authenticate every single item to guarantee its legitimacy.
This process is costly, requiring specialized knowledge and significant operational overhead.
They also invest heavily in high-quality photography, detailed descriptions, and target marketing towards buyers specifically looking for authenticated luxury goods.
This added layer of trust and service justifies a higher commission rate compared to platforms like Poshmark or ThredUp, which don’t offer the same level of authentication scrutiny or specialize exclusively in luxury.
Buyers on The RealReal are often willing to pay a premium for the assurance of authenticity, which helps offset the higher fees for sellers by potentially achieving higher sale prices in the first place. It’s a different value proposition entirely.
Does The RealReal’s authentication process truly justify their higher fees for luxury goods?
For many sellers of high-end luxury items, yes, The RealReal‘s authentication process does justify the higher fees. Here’s why: selling counterfeit luxury goods, even unknowingly, can expose you to significant legal risks and reputational damage. Buyers in the luxury market are extremely wary of fakes, especially when spending thousands of dollars. The RealReal removes this burden of proof and risk from the seller by providing expert authentication. This guarantees to the buyer that the item is legitimate, which builds trust and facilitates sales of expensive pieces that might be difficult or risky to sell on less specialized platforms like Facebook Marketplace or even eBay without specific authentication services. While the fees are higher, the combination of access to a dedicated luxury buyer base, professional presentation, and guaranteed authenticity can lead to a higher final sale price and a smoother transaction, making it a worthwhile trade-off for valuable items that demand this level of service and buyer confidence.
What are the typical shipping and insurance costs like when using The RealReal?
Shipping high-value luxury items, which is The RealReal‘s bread and butter, naturally involves higher costs compared to shipping a t-shirt sold on Poshmark. The RealReal uses specialized packaging and often includes insurance to protect against loss or damage during transit.
While the specifics can vary, these enhanced shipping and insurance protocols are factored into the overall cost structure, potentially either directly charged to the seller or built into the commission percentage.
For the seller, this means less worry about an expensive item getting lost or damaged, but it comes at a premium.
It’s a necessary cost for handling goods of this value and helps maintain buyer confidence by ensuring items arrive safely and securely.
It’s part of the white-glove service they provide for luxury consignment.
How does Poshmark’s percentage-based fee work, and is it fixed?
Poshmark keeps their fee structure relatively simple, which is part of their appeal. For sales under $15, the fee is a flat $2.95. For sales of $15 or more, Poshmark takes a flat 20% commission on the final sale price. This percentage is fixed. it doesn’t change based on the item’s brand, category, or how expensive it is as long as it’s $15+. This predictability is a major advantage. You know exactly what cut Poshmark will take before you even list your item, which makes pricing straightforward. There are no hidden listing fees or variable percentages based on complex criteria like on ThredUp or Vestiaire Collective. The only real cost uncertainty on Poshmark comes from potential returns or disputes, but the core selling fee is transparent and fixed once the sale price is known.
What are the key pros and cons of using Poshmark’s large user base?
The biggest pro of Poshmark‘s massive user base is sheer reach. You’re instantly exposing your items to millions of active shoppers specifically looking for fashion items. This dramatically increases the likelihood of finding a buyer compared to trying to sell locally on Facebook Marketplace or building an audience from scratch on eBay. The con? Fierce competition. With millions of other sellers and countless items listed, your listing can easily get buried unless you actively work to make it stand out. This requires high-quality photos, competitive pricing, engaging with the community, and consistent activity. You’re trading a readily available audience for the challenge of being seen within a crowded marketplace. It’s not a platform where you can just list and forget. you need to be proactive to leverage that huge audience effectively.
What are some effective strategies to increase sales and visibility on Poshmark?
Since Poshmark is crowded, you need to be smart. First, high-quality photos are non-negotiable. Clear, well-lit pictures from multiple angles showing the item accurately are essential. Second, detailed and accurate descriptions using relevant keywords help buyers find your items in search and build trust. Third, competitive pricing is key – research what similar items are selling for. Fourth, be active! Share your own listings multiple times a day, share other sellers’ listings they might reciprocate, and participate in Posh Parties. The more active you are, the more visible your closet becomes. Fifth, offer discounts or bundle deals to incentivize buyers. Sixth, provide excellent customer service – respond quickly to questions, ship promptly, and package nicely. Unlike simply sending a kit to ThredUp, success on Poshmark is directly linked to your effort in presenting and promoting your items and engaging with the community.
How is Tradesy’s fee structure similar or different from Poshmark’s?
Both Tradesy and Poshmark use a percentage-based fee model, meaning they take a cut of your final sale price. This is similar in principle, making them distinct from models like ThredUp‘s payout system or eBay‘s listing + selling fee combo. Where they can differ is the specific percentage and potentially how it’s applied. Poshmark has its fixed $2.95 or 20% structure. Tradesy‘s percentage can sometimes vary depending on the item’s price, category, or other factors, potentially leading to a different net payout compared to Poshmark for the exact same item. It’s crucial to check Tradesy‘s current fee structure on their site for the most accurate comparison for your specific items. The core similarity is the percentage cut from the sale, but the exact numbers can differ, impacting your final profit margin.
What is Tradesy’s target audience, and how does that affect what sells well there?
Tradesy carved out its niche primarily focusing on women’s designer and upscale fashion. Their target audience is women looking for pre-owned contemporary and luxury clothing, shoes, and accessories. This contrasts with the broader audience on Poshmark, which spans fast fashion to high-end, or the everything-under-the-sun approach of eBay and Facebook Marketplace. Because Tradesy‘s audience is more focused, items from recognized mid-range to high-end women’s fashion brands tend to perform well. If you have authentic pieces from brands commonly found in department stores or luxury boutiques, they are likely a better fit for Tradesy‘s audience and could fetch a better price or sell faster there than on a more general platform. Understanding this specific demographic is key to listing items that resonate with their buyers.
How do listing fees and selling fees work differently on eBay compared to consignment platforms?
eBay‘s fee structure is multi-layered, which sets it apart from simple consignment models like Poshmark or Tradesy. First, eBay often charges insertion fees listing fees when you list an item, although private sellers get a certain number of free listings per month. This is a cost incurred before anything sells, unlike most consignment platforms where the fee is only taken upon sale except potentially for premium services. Second, when an item does sell, eBay charges a final value fee selling fee, which is typically a percentage of the final sale price, including shipping costs. The exact percentage varies significantly based on the item category. So, with eBay, you might pay to list, and then you pay a percentage when it sells. Consignment platforms usually just charge a percentage or flat fee upon the successful sale, bundling the cost of listing, marketing, etc., into that one fee. This makes eBay‘s fees potentially more complex to calculate upfront, but it offers greater control over the listing process itself.
What are the best ways to optimize my eBay listings to attract buyers and maximize profit?
Optimizing your eBay listings is crucial because you’re competing in a vast marketplace with everything from collectibles to clothing. Start with compelling titles using relevant keywords that buyers would actually search for. Use high-quality photos from multiple angles showing the item clearly – think bright lighting, clear background. Write detailed and accurate descriptions, including measurements, condition specifics, and any flaws. Competitive pricing is a must. research completed sales for similar items to price effectively. Use eBay’s category and item specifics properly. filling these out helps your item appear in filtered searches. Consider offering free shipping building the cost into your price as this is attractive to buyers. Respond quickly and professionally to buyer questions. Finally, maintain excellent seller feedback by describing items accurately and shipping promptly. a good reputation builds trust and encourages future sales. It’s a hands-on process requiring attention to detail, unlike the “send-it-and-forget-it” model of ThredUp.
How does eBay’s buyer protection impact sellers and potential fees?
eBay‘s buyer protection program is designed to give buyers confidence by guaranteeing they receive the item described or get their money back. While this builds trust in the marketplace overall which benefits sellers by attracting buyers, it also puts significant responsibility on the seller. If a buyer claims an item isn’t as described, is damaged, or never arrived, eBay often sides with the buyer, potentially forcing the seller to accept a return and issue a refund, even if they disagree with the buyer’s claim. This can lead to losses for the seller original fees paid, shipping costs, potential return shipping. While there isn’t a direct fee for buyer protection itself, the risk it introduces means sellers must be extremely diligent in their listings – describing items perfectly, packaging securely, and shipping on time with tracking. Failure to do so increases the risk of disputes, forced refunds, negative feedback, and potentially penalties from eBay, which can impact your selling fees in the long run if your seller performance rating drops. It’s a system that requires careful management to avoid costly problems.
Is Facebook Marketplace truly a “free” option for consignment, or are there hidden costs?
On the surface, Facebook Marketplace seems free because there are no listing fees and no percentage cut taken by Facebook for individual sales they do charge fees for shops and some specific categories, but for typical person-to-person item sales, it’s free. However, calling it truly “free” is misleading because of the significant hidden costs. The primary cost is your time and effort. You are entirely responsible for taking photos, writing descriptions, interacting with potentially numerous buyers many of whom may not be serious, coordinating meetups or shipping, handling payments directly, and dealing with any post-sale issues or disputes yourself. There is no built-in buyer or seller protection from Facebook for these peer-to-peer transactions, unlike the systems on Poshmark, eBay, or The RealReal. The time spent managing inquiries, no-shows, and potential scams is a real cost. Also, while you can boost listings for a fee, organic reach relies heavily on the Facebook algorithm and sharing. So, while no explicit dollar fee is taken per sale, the manual labor, lack of protection, and marketing effort represent significant implicit costs.
How can I effectively reach buyers when selling items on Facebook Marketplace?
Reaching buyers effectively on Facebook Marketplace relies more on personal effort and leveraging the platform’s local focus. First, high-quality photos are essential, just like anywhere else. Use multiple clear pictures. Write detailed descriptions including condition, size, brand mentioning brands like those sold on Poshmark or Tradesy can attract relevant buyers, and relevant keywords. Specify if the item is for local pickup, shipping, or both. Be very responsive to messages. buyers on Facebook often expect quick replies. Leverage local buy/sell groups. listing your item in relevant local groups in addition to the main Marketplace can expand your reach within your area, which is great for larger items or avoiding shipping costs. Be willing to negotiate, as haggling is common on the platform. Finally, share your listing on your own profile if you’re comfortable to tap into your personal network. It’s a more direct, less automated form of selling compared to dedicated platforms.
What are the primary risks and rewards of selling items on Facebook Marketplace?
The rewards of using Facebook Marketplace are straightforward: no direct fees on sales for individual listings, local transactions are easy to arrange saving on shipping, and you have access to a massive local audience. You keep 100% of the sale price you agree upon with the buyer. However, the risks are significant, largely due to the lack of built-in protection. You’re responsible for vetting buyers yourself. This exposes you to potential scams, no-shows for meetups, disputes with no platform mediation, and dealing with potentially unsafe transaction environments if meeting strangers in person. Unlike the structured payment systems and dispute resolution on eBay or Poshmark, you’re on your own. You also have to handle payment collection directly cash, Venmo, etc., which adds complexity and potential risk. It’s a high-autonomy, potentially high-return but also high-risk option that requires vigilance and smart practices to navigate safely.
How does Vestiaire Collective’s fee structure compare to The RealReal’s for luxury goods?
Vestiaire Collective, like The RealReal, specializes in luxury consignment, and both have fee structures that reflect this high-end market. However, their specific structures can differ.
Vestiaire Collective uses a complex tiered commission system that can vary based on the item’s price, category, and seller location.
They also often add a payment processing fee and potentially a fixed listing fee for lower-priced items.
While both platforms have higher fees than general marketplaces, Vestiaire Collective‘s structure might involve more variable components or additional fixed fees compared to The RealReal‘s percentage-focused model.
You really need to look at the specific fee breakdown for your item on each platform to see which one offers a better potential net return.
Neither is as simple as the fixed percentage on Poshmark.
What is the value proposition of Vestiaire Collective’s authenticity verification process?
Similar to The RealReal, Vestiaire Collective‘s main value proposition for both buyers and sellers is its rigorous authenticity verification process.
For buyers, this is paramount when purchasing pre-owned luxury items online.
The guarantee of authenticity builds trust and encourages high-value purchases.
For sellers, it provides a legitimate platform to sell expensive designer items without having to personally convince buyers of the item’s authenticity, a major challenge on platforms like eBay or Facebook Marketplace. Vestiaire Collective experts physically inspect items upon sale or in some cases, before listing, adding a crucial layer of security.
This service is costly to provide, and that cost is reflected in their fees, but for luxury items where authenticity is key to achieving a high sale price, it’s often seen as a necessary and worthwhile investment.
How does Vestiaire Collective’s marketing and reach compare to other platforms like Poshmark or The RealReal?
Vestiaire Collective targets a specific, international audience of luxury fashion enthusiasts. Their marketing efforts are aimed squarely at this demographic, using curated collections and editorial content to appeal to high-end buyers. While their overall user base might not be as large as Poshmark‘s general fashion audience or eBay‘s massive global reach, their audience is highly targeted and specifically seeking luxury goods. This means that while fewer eyes might see your listing compared to Poshmark, the eyes that do are more likely to be serious, qualified buyers for luxury items. The RealReal also focuses on luxury but might have a slightly broader appeal within that market spectrum. Vestiaire Collective‘s reach is niche but potentially highly effective if your items perfectly match their luxury, fashion-forward aesthetic. You’re trading broad exposure for targeted visibility.
Which platforms are best for selling high-value luxury items, considering fees and services?
For high-value luxury items think designer handbags, fine jewelry, high-end watches, couture fashion, platforms specializing in luxury consignment are generally your best bet, despite their higher fees. The RealReal and Vestiaire Collective are the top contenders here. Both offer expert authentication, which is critical for buyer trust and achieving a high sale price for luxury goods. They also cater to a dedicated audience of luxury buyers and provide professional listing services photography, descriptions that are essential for presenting high-end items appropriately. While their fees are higher than general platforms like Poshmark or eBay, the services, authentication, and access to the right buyers often result in a higher net return for genuinely valuable pieces compared to selling them elsewhere where buyers might be hesitant due to authenticity concerns or the overall platform isn’t geared towards premium goods. Selling a $5,000 bag on Facebook Marketplace is just asking for trouble.
Which platforms are generally better for selling mid-range or contemporary fashion items?
For mid-range and contemporary fashion items brands you’d find at places like Nordstrom, Anthropologie, or higher-end mall stores, platforms with a broad fashion focus but reasonable fees are usually the sweet spot. Poshmark is a powerhouse here, with its massive user base and straightforward 20% fee structure for sales over $15. Tradesy is also a strong contender, especially for women’s fashion, with its targeted audience, though their fees can vary. eBay can also work, especially if you have desirable brands and optimize your listings, though you need to factor in listing fees and varied selling fees. ThredUp offers unparalleled convenience for offloading a large volume of contemporary items quickly, but you sacrifice control and potentially get a much lower payout percentage, making it less ideal if maximizing profit is your primary goal. Avoid high-end luxury platforms like The RealReal or Vestiaire Collective for these items, as their fees and services are overkill and won’t add proportional value for mid-range goods.
Which platforms are best for selling lower-value items or fast fashion?
For lower-value items or fast fashion pieces brands like Zara, H&M, Forever 21, etc., you need to be realistic about the potential return, as consignment fees can quickly eat up any profit. Poshmark is a possibility, but be mindful of their $2.95 fee for sales under $15 – if your item sells for $5, you’re left with $2.05. Their 20% fee on items over $15 can still make sense if the items sell for $20-$30+. ThredUp is often used for these items primarily for the convenience of mass clean-outs, but the payout per item will likely be very low, perhaps just a few dollars or even cents, and many items might not be accepted at all. Facebook Marketplace with its zero selling fees for typical listings is potentially the most profitable option for very low-value items if you can sell them locally and avoid shipping costs and the hassle. Selling fast fashion individually on platforms like eBay, Tradesy, The RealReal, or Vestiaire Collective is generally not recommended due to fees, target audience, or the sheer effort involved relative to the minimal potential payout. It often makes more sense to bundle fast fashion items or use a bulk-processing service like ThredUp for convenience, even if the payout is small.
Besides fees, what are the main factors to consider when choosing a consignment platform?
Beyond just the fees, several crucial factors should drive your platform choice. First, consider the platform’s target audience and whether it aligns with the items you’re selling e.g., luxury on The RealReal vs. general fashion on Poshmark. Second, evaluate the level of effort required from you – do you want a hands-off experience like ThredUp low effort, low control or are you willing to list, photograph, and ship yourself for potentially higher returns and control like on Poshmark or eBay? Third, look at the platform’s policies regarding returns, disputes, and buyer/seller protection. How do they handle issues, and what are your risks especially important on places like Facebook Marketplace? Fourth, consider shipping logistics and costs – who pays, who ships, is insurance included? Finally, assess the platform’s reputation and how effectively they market themselves and attract buyers. A platform with higher fees but a proven track record of selling items like yours to the right audience might be a better choice than a cheaper platform where your items just sit.
Does the condition of my items affect the consignment fee I pay?
Generally, the platform’s core consignment fee the percentage or flat rate doesn’t directly change based on the condition of your item on most major platforms like Poshmark, Tradesy, or The RealReal. The fee is applied to the final sale price, and the condition affects that sale price. An item in excellent condition will likely sell for more, meaning the platform’s percentage cut will be higher in dollar terms, but the rate remains the same. However, condition critically affects whether a platform will accept your item in the first place especially curated platforms like The RealReal, Vestiaire Collective, or ThredUp, and it absolutely impacts how quickly it sells and the price it fetches. So, while the fee percentage itself might not change, the net amount you receive is hugely dependent on the condition. Some platforms might have processing fees that vary slightly based on the cleaning or repair needed, but this is separate from the main consignment commission. Always aim to consign items in the best possible condition to maximize your payout regardless of the fee structure.
How long does it typically take to receive payment after an item sells on different consignment platforms?
Payment timelines vary significantly by platform. With Poshmark, once the buyer receives the item and accepts it or 3 days pass after delivery without them reporting an issue, your earnings are released to your Poshmark balance, and you can then transfer it to your bank via direct deposit which can take a few business days. eBay, through Managed Payments, typically processes payouts to your bank within 1-3 business days after the buyer pays and the transaction is confirmed sometimes held longer for new sellers or high-risk transactions. The RealReal and Vestiaire Collective often have longer payment cycles due to their authentication processes. payouts might occur weeks after the sale is completed and authenticated. ThredUp has its own system where you earn credit upon acceptance or cash upon sale, with specific payout options and timelines. Tradesy also has a payout process after sale and delivery. Facebook Marketplace sales are peer-to-peer, so payment is immediate upon transaction cash in hand, instant transfer via Venmo, etc., but without platform security. Always check the specific platform’s payout policy before consigning if quick access to funds is important to you.
What happens if an item doesn’t sell? Are there fees for unsold items?
Policies for unsold items vary greatly between platforms. On platforms where you list and manage the item yourself like Poshmark, Tradesy, eBay, Facebook Marketplace, there are generally no additional fees if an item doesn’t sell aside from eBay’s initial listing fees if applicable. You simply relist it, keep it, or dispose of it as you wish. The cost is your time and the initial listing fee if you paid one. For platforms where you send items in The RealReal, Vestiaire Collective, ThredUp, the situation is different. They typically consign items for a set period e.g., 90-180 days. If an item doesn’t sell within that time, you usually have options: reclaim the item often for a return shipping/processing fee, allow the platform to donate or recycle it, or in some cases, relist it at a discounted price. The critical point here is the potential for return fees if you want the item back, which can negate earnings from sold items or result in a net loss if nothing sells. ThredUp is notable for often donating/recycling items they don’t accept or sell without option for return unless you pay upfront fees.
How important are photos and descriptions in influencing the final sale price and offsetting fees?
Crucially important. On platforms where you create the listing like Poshmark, Tradesy, eBay, Facebook Marketplace, high-quality photos and detailed, accurate descriptions are paramount. They are the primary way you attract buyers and build trust. Poor photos or vague descriptions lead to fewer views, less interest, lower offers, and potentially disputes. Excellent presentation allows you to price more competitively and increases the likelihood of a quick sale at a good price. Even on platforms like The RealReal or Vestiaire Collective where they handle photography, providing them with the item in great condition helps them get the best possible photos and descriptions, leading to a better sale price. A higher sale price, even with a percentage fee, means more money in your pocket. Think of great photos and descriptions as free marketing that directly impacts how much you can get for your item, effectively reducing the relative impact of the fees on your profit margin.
Can consigning lower-value items individually be unprofitable after fees?
Absolutely, yes. This is a common pitfall if you don’t do the math upfront. If a platform charges a percentage fee, and you sell a low-value item say, $10 with a 20% fee Poshmark, for sales over $15, has a $2.95 flat fee, you’re left with $8 before considering any other potential costs like shipping supplies or your time. If the fee is flat $2.95 on Poshmark for items <$15, selling that $10 item leaves you with just $7.05. If you factor in potential return shipping costs on platforms where that’s a risk or the value of your time, selling very low-value items individually through consignment can easily become unprofitable. This is why people often bundle lower-value items or use bulk services like ThredUp, where the payout per item might be minimal, but the overall return on a large volume makes the effort worthwhile, or they sell them locally on Facebook Marketplace to avoid fees altogether. Always calculate your potential net return before listing those cheaper items individually.
How do returns and disputes impact the fees I’ve already paid or expect to receive?
Returns and disputes are the headaches of online selling and can definitely mess with your fee calculations. On most consignment platforms, if a buyer returns an item and the return is accepted due to item not as described, damage in transit, etc., the sale is essentially cancelled. This means you do not receive the payout, and the platform refunds the fee they initially charged on that sale. So, while you don’t lose the fee itself, you lose the potential earnings and potentially incur other costs like return shipping. Platforms like Poshmark and eBay have structured dispute resolution processes. On platforms where they handle the sale entirely The RealReal, Vestiaire Collective, they manage the return, and you simply don’t get paid for that specific item. On Facebook Marketplace, there’s no platform involvement, so you have to handle returns and disputes yourself, which carries the risk of scams or losing the item and the money. Accuracy in your listings is the best defense against returns impacting your fees and earnings.
Is it ever better to sell outright rather than consign, considering fees?
Yes, absolutely. Consignment is a service, and you pay for that service with fees. If you have the time, knowledge, and willingness to sell items yourself directly to a buyer e.g., listing on eBay and handling everything, selling locally on Facebook Marketplace, or even using platforms like Poshmark where you control the listing, you might net a higher percentage of the final sale price because you’re not paying the full consignment fee. However, selling yourself requires significant effort: taking photos, writing descriptions, marketing, answering questions, packaging, shipping, and managing potential returns or issues. Consignment platforms, especially full-service ones like The RealReal or even the convenient but lower-payout ThredUp, take most of this work off your plate. The decision boils down to this trade-off: is the money you save by avoiding consignment fees worth the extra time and effort you have to put in? For high-value items, the authentication and targeted audience of platforms like Vestiaire Collective might make consignment worthwhile despite fees. For lower-value items or bulk clean-outs, convenience might outweigh maximizing every dollar.
How do consignment fees on clothing compare to other categories like furniture or electronics?
Consignment fees and structures can vary significantly by category, reflecting the different markets, handling requirements, and buyer expectations. For clothing and fashion items, percentage-based fees 20-40% or more, sometimes tiered are very common on platforms like Poshmark, Tradesy, The RealReal, and Vestiaire Collective, as are the payout structures on ThredUp. Furniture consignment typically involves local stores online platforms are less common due to shipping challenges and often has higher percentage fees sometimes 40-60%+ because of the large size, storage needs, and lower turnover rate compared to clothing. Electronics are often sold directly by the owner on marketplaces like eBay or Facebook Marketplace, where fees are listing/selling based rather than a straight consignment model. When electronics are consigned, fees can be variable depending on the item’s value and condition. The fee structure is tailored to the specifics of selling within that category – the handling, storage, testing, and market dynamics all play a role in determining the cost of consignment.
Are there any platform-specific fees I should know about beyond the standard commission?
Yes, absolutely, and this is where reading the fine print is crucial. Beyond the main percentage or flat fee, platforms might charge for various services. The RealReal and Vestiaire Collective might include insurance costs in shipping or have fees related to authentication. ThredUp has fees if you want unaccepted items returned, or potential processing fees. eBay has insertion fees, optional listing upgrades like bolding, subtitles, and potentially fees for using features like Promoted Listings. Poshmark generally keeps it simple with the $2.95/$15+ fee, but shipping costs paid by the buyer are distinct. Tradesy might have varying percentage structures. Facebook Marketplace doesn’t have per-item fees for standard listings but charges for optional boosting or for using Shops features. Always look for sections on “Fees,” “Costs,” or “How You Get Paid” on a platform’s website before you commit to consigning your items. Don’t assume the prominently displayed percentage is the only cost.
How does seasonality affect what items I should consign and potentially the fees or payout?
Seasonality is a huge factor, especially in fashion consignment, and it absolutely affects what sells and how quickly, which can indirectly impact your overall return after fees. Consigning out-of-season items means they’ll likely sit longer, potentially requiring price drops reducing your final payout and thus the dollar amount the fee is applied to, or they might expire on platforms with time limits. Platforms like ThredUp are often more likely to accept and give a better payout for in-season items they can move quickly. Listing a heavy winter coat on Poshmark in July means it might get less attention than it would in September. While the percentage fee on Poshmark or Tradesy doesn’t change based on seasonality, the lower selling price you might have to accept does impact your profit. For platforms like The RealReal or Vestiaire Collective, while luxury pieces have longer shelf lives, even they see increased activity for seasonal items. Timing your consignments with the appropriate season increases the chances of a faster sale at a better price, maximizing your net profit after fees.
Is there a benefit to building a seller reputation on platforms like Poshmark or eBay in terms of fees or sales?
Building a strong seller reputation is incredibly beneficial on platforms like Poshmark and eBay, although it doesn’t typically result in a lower percentage fee directly. The benefit comes from increased buyer trust and visibility. On eBay, high seller ratings and achieving “Top Rated Seller” status can qualify you for lower final value fees in certain categories and better placement in search results. On Poshmark, being a “Posh Ambassador” earned through consistent sales and good ratings doesn’t change the fee structure but gives you increased visibility and potentially more followers, leading to more sales. Both platforms prioritize sellers with good track records. Buyers are more likely to purchase from a seller with positive feedback and a history of successful transactions. This increased trust and visibility lead to more sales, potentially at better prices, which ultimately means more money in your pocket even after paying the standard fees. It’s an investment in your long-term success on the platform.
Should I factor in the cost of my time when calculating the “true” cost of consignment fees?
Absolutely, factoring in the value of your time is critical if you want an accurate picture of your net return, especially on platforms where you handle the listing and selling process yourself. For platforms like Poshmark, Tradesy, eBay, or Facebook Marketplace, you spend time sorting, cleaning, photographing, writing descriptions, listing, answering questions, negotiating, packaging, and shipping or arranging meetups. This time has value. While consignment fees are the explicit dollar cost from the platform, your time is an implicit cost. If you spend hours selling a few low-value items, your hourly return might be negligible or even negative, despite paying the standard platform fee. Platforms like The RealReal, Vestiaire Collective, or ThredUp reduce your time investment significantly, which is part of what you’re paying for with their fees. When choosing a platform and pricing your items, consider how much your time is worth and which platform offers the best balance between fees and the amount of work you have to do.
How do consignment fees factor into pricing strategy? Should I price higher to offset them?
Yes, absolutely! Consignment fees are a direct cost of selling, and they must be factored into your pricing strategy if you want to make a profit. If you want to net a certain amount from an item, you need to price it high enough so that after the platform takes its cut whether it’s Poshmark‘s 20%, The RealReal‘s variable luxury rate, or eBay‘s final value fee, you’re left with your desired amount. You can’t just look at what similar items sold for on Facebook Marketplace where there are no fees and apply that price to Tradesy where there are fees. For example, if you want to make $80 from an item on a platform with a 20% fee, you need to price it at $100 $100 – 20% of $100 = $80. If you priced it at $80, you’d only pocket $64 $80 – 20% of $80. Understanding the specific fee structure of Vestiaire Collective, Poshmark, or any other platform you use is step one in determining your minimum acceptable selling price and setting a competitive list price that accounts for the fee and potential offers.
What’s the difference in fees between selling a single item vs. selling a bundle or lot?
This primarily applies to platforms where you control the listing and fees are per transaction, like Poshmark or eBay. On Poshmark, their fee is 20% on sales $15+, regardless of whether it’s a single item or a bundle. So, selling a bundle of three items for $60 incurs a $12 fee 20% of $60, leaving you $48. Selling those same three items individually for $20 each would mean a $4 fee per item $20 * 20%, totaling $12 in fees, leaving you $48. The fee percentage is the same, but bundling saves the buyer on shipping making the deal more attractive and saves you the effort of listing and shipping multiple times. On eBay, final value fees are also a percentage of the total sale including shipping. Listing fees might be per listing, so bundling into one listing saves on potential listing fees compared to creating multiple individual listings. For bulk processors like ThredUp, bundling is inherent as you send a bag, and they process items individually for payout. For platforms like The RealReal or Vestiaire Collective, you generally consign items individually regardless of value. Bundling is most effective on platforms like Poshmark where the structure encourages combining items from one seller.
Leave a Reply